Showing posts with label Tesco. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tesco. Show all posts

Wednesday, 11 February 2015

Tesco Growing, Discounters Slowing, But No Sign of a Return to Traditional Shopper Behaviour

Its a funny old world when grocery market watchers are full of smiles when Tesco manages to grow by 0.3% in the 12 weeks to 1st February 2015, but signal gloom because discounters Aldi and Lidl “only” grew by 21% and 14% over the same period. (Kantar Worldpanel)

It depends where the start point is of course and a move into positive growth for Tesco after months of dropping sales probably does seem like a turning point. Equally, when a company has been growing by over 30% year on year as is the case with Aldi, then a slow down to 21% may seem like a turning point too.

What is clear though is that there is no sign of a rush back to traditional mainstream shopping patterns. Sainsbury's sales are declining by 1% and Asda by 1.7%, and the evidence suggests that the march of the discount grocers is likely to continue, albeit at slightly lower growth rates.

Take for example Aldi’s stated plans. They have committed to opening 70 more stores in 2015, and one of these will be its biggest ever, at 19,0000 sq feet compared with an average of 16,000 sq ft just now. More stores mean more shoppers, and bigger stores with their capacity to offer a wider range may mean a bigger spend per shopper.

There is no doubt that increasing numbers of us go to discounters. The IGD says that 55% of shoppers visited a discounter in December 2014 versus 36% in December 2010. This could be due to well publicised offers on alcohol, but there are also signs that increasing numbers are using discounters to do their main shop – 15% in December 2014 versus 3% in December 2010. And shoppers seem to like what they find when they get there - 52% of those visiting a discount shop spend over half their food and grocery shopping budget there.

Whilst it is the retailers who tend to get the headlines, the changing shape of the grocery market continues to cause headaches for suppliers. There are the well documented demands for reduced prices and extended payment terms from the big 4 mainstream grocers, and in a total grocery market which is growing by just over 1% the demands are rarely compensated for by growth. The problems then deepen, as the discount sector which is showing growth, tends not to stock brands, and buys most of its product lines from abroad.



Monday, 13 October 2014

Supermarket Price Promises – Mostly Smoke and Mirrors

Shoppers’ continued search for value, and the onslaught of discount grocers has led to the Big 4 supermarkets are tying themselves in knots trying to assure their shoppers that they offer the same prices as their competitors.

All claim that the shopper can be confident that their purchases will be no more expensive than if they had bought elsewhere, but close examination suggests that the initiatives being run by the supermarkets are mostly smoke and mirrors designed to give the illusion of value but in reality offering little of substance.

No store hands back hard cash if they are found to be more expensive. Instead Tesco, Sainsbury and Asda hand over vouchers and Morrisons has a complicated scheme where a card has to be obtained, points are added to the card when purchase at another store would have been cheaper, and the points are eventually traded in for a voucher. Voucher schemes benefit the supermarket because many will have been lost or forgotten about before they expire.
There are other wheezes designed to limit supermarket exposure. Sainsbury only compares with Asda, dropping the comparison with Tesco in a recent change designed to save money. Asda makes the shopper do the comparison work. It guarantees to be 10% cheaper than the other three major supermarkets but the shopper has to go online, enter till receipt details to find if their shop could have been cheaper elsewhere, and then claim their voucher.
There are a myriad of exclusions and exceptions to the various price promises. To be fair, Tesco’s Price Match covers all shops big and small, and fresh and own label products as well as branded. Morrisons compares with Lidl and Aldi as well as the majors across branded and own label. But Sainsbury does not offer its Brand Match in convenience stores, neither does Morrisons, and Sainsbury only compares branded prices.  All the supermarkets stipulate a minimum spend. No store gives out a voucher worth more than £10. Many everyday items are excluded such as baby formula.
There will be shoppers who have the time to go into the detail and work out how to make these pricing initiatives work in their favour. Many though will quickly conclude that the only thing that counts when shopping is the size of the bill week in and week out.
Which takes us back to Lidl and Aldi.
Despite the flurry of reduced prices and price promises among the “Big 4” both discount stores continue to flourish. Add to this Aldi’s recent commitment to keep the price differential between themselves and conventional supermarkets at a minimum of 15%, and it is difficult to see how the majors can hold their position without concrete and continued price reductions across their whole range of goods. So far, they are only playing at delivering competitive prices.




Tuesday, 24 April 2012

Tesco Recovery Plan - Not Radical Enough


Following January’s shock profits warning Philip Clarke, CEO of Tesco, has set out what he will do to restore growth to the UK, and one is left with the feeling that a player with nearly a third of the market, and nearly twice as big as its nearest rival could have come up with something more imaginative.  

The main planks of Clarke’s plan are:

 Sharper prices

More staff to keep the shelves filled

Better quality products

Nicer looking stores

Clearer marketing messages about why shoppers should choose Tesco over the competition

Easier shopping over the internet including the chance to order on line and pick up in store

Less store openings

It is difficult to argue with any of this, but reaction has been tepid, the general view being that Tesco have underestimated the how difficult it will be to get back on track at a time when their competition is being uniformly successful.

Clarke has admitted that Tesco has lost touch with its customers, and is now committed to getting them to love Tesco again. He is aiming for warm and cuddly versus cold and hard.

 However, scale does not have to be bad. Used wisely scale confers terrific business advantage. Philip Clarke could have seen scale as a power for good and used it to provide exciting plans that really would make a difference to Tesco’s growth prospects.

Tesco’s scale means they employ more people, and so have a bigger net from which to catch the truly talented.

They have bigger research and development budgets which should mean market leading innovation in products and services

They have huge marketing budgets which gives them the chance to communicate to more people, more often and through more channels.

 They have unparalleled purchasing power which they could use to support suppliers in return for lower prices rather than just bully.

So Tesco could have faced the world last Wednesday with a commitment to using scale to do good. They could have announced bigger budgets for research and development, a revised innovation process to get new ideas to market more quickly, a new supplier code of conduct, and even a deeper drive to provide the pricing and value that hard pressed shopper need in the current difficult economic climate. Instead we got a standard list of actions that every other supermarket is implementing.

What Philip Clarke’s announcement lacked was an overarching view of how Tesco could be made different and special again, so that customers do indeed find that shopping in Tesco delivers what they seek, if not an experience that they will love.


Tuesday, 20 March 2012

More Staff and Brighter Stores Won't Cut It - Tesco Needs a Culture Change


It is not often that a business story makes headline news but that is what happened when Philip Clarke of Tesco announced that he would start managing their UK arm direct, leading to the resignation of the man he appointed to run the business just a year ago.

The news prompted a rush of comment from investment analysts and business writers. Most referred to a profits warning following a disastrous  Xmas where a much publicised £500m price drop campaign actually turned out not to be such a good deal after all with customers instead going to other supermarkets where prices were not much different but the shopping experience much more pleasant. Deeper digging though shows that Tesco’s troubles have been going on for years. Market share, that critical barometer of competitiveness has been steadily dropping, and sales per square foot have been declining.
How did the mighty Tesco, much trumpeted taker of 1 in 8 pounds spent on retail products, get to such a state. The commentators talk about the resurgence of the other big supermarkets, Morrisons, Sainsbury and ADSA, and the growth of Waitrose at the top end of the market,  and discounter ALDI , all putting a squeeze on Tesco’s middle ground position. They talk of non availability of funds for investment in the UK because of the drain on resources from overseas investment. They point to structural issues like the rise of on line shopping making purchase of items such as books and CD’s in store less attractive.

Philip Clarke’s reasons for taking control of the UK are that “Greater focus will allow me to oversee the improvements that are so important for our customers”. To this end he plans to invest in more people and more exciting stores.
Clarke and the analysts have overlooked a key issue - it is arrogance that has landed Tesco in its current difficulties. Tesco has believed that it is so big and powerful it can treat customers (and suppliers) how it wants, and get away with it.

 It has forgotten the most fundamental principle of business success, namely that you ignore your customers at your peril. For years every article about Tesco has received hundreds of comments about the customer experience, some good, but mostly bad. Even a cursory tracking of shopper views across the internet, on Twitter, on social networking sites like Mumsnet would have revealed how many claimed to be fed up with shopping at Tesco. Tesco’s own market research must have told them this too. Yet, they did not act.
So, unless Mr. Clarke leads culture change at Tesco, shows some humility, and pays more than lip service to what shoppers want, brighter stores and more assistants at the fresh food counter won’t turn this ship around.  It remains to be seen whether a person who started at Tesco when he was 14 stacking shelves in his father’s store and been with them all his working life can recognise and correct the cultural issues.


Friday, 13 January 2012

Tesco Pays the Price for Ignoring its Customers



It’s been a dramatic week for  supermarket watchers.

First, Morrisons who had been the clear leaders in the grocery war of late announced that their sales over Xmas period had grown by a tiny 0.7%. Dalton Phillips their Canadian chief executive said it was because cash strapped Brits were unwilling to splash out over the festive season.
Somewhat contrary to this picture of austerity consciousness, Waitrose announced sales growth of +3.8%. Now as anyone who has ventured through the doors of a Waitrose will know their food is not cheap, even following much publicised activities such as a price match with Tesco on 1000 lines.  Next came Marks and Spencer, also not a cheap place to shop, with sales growth of 3%. According to ex Morrisons chief executive Marc Bolland this was due to the introduction of 600 new products, and keen pricing on some lines. Indeed M&S customers seem to be gregarious types, powering sales of party packs of food to by 8% and fresh turkey by 25%.

Then we heard from Sainsbury with sales up 2.1%. According to their head man Justin King, their premium Taste the Difference range grew by 10%, but he did concede that at the other end of the scale their cheaper value range grew by 7%.

We have not heard from ASDA yet but they are reported by market researchers Nielsen to have had a good Christmas sales performance also.
And what can we say about Tesco whose Christmas trading performance was nothing short of dire, with sales down 2.3%. It is not just a short term issue either.  According to their chief executive Philip Clarke, Tesco’s “entire shopping experience” is not as good as it should be and he indicated that Tesco has failed for years to deliver on product availability, service and food quality.

And thereby hangs the clue as to what makes the difference between winners and losers. Yes, indeed British consumers are feeling the pinch, scrutinising all costs, budgeting, cutting down on waste. But, they are prepared to spend their money with grocers who offer the combination of price, quality, and specialness which makes them feel as if their money has been well spent.
The “upmarket” grocers between them have about 25% of the market and despite cash strapped times were rewarded because they offered that critical concept of value for money that consumers seek, especially when money is tight.

Those who keep close to their customers and listen to them generally do well. Tesco has not been listening, and has not done so for years, resulting in lost customers and falling market share.
Turning a deaf ear to customer needs leads to problems.  

Wednesday, 27 July 2011

Supermarkets' Own Brands - An Increasingly Important Battleground

For the first time in a long time supermarkets are struggling to grow food sales. Food inflation of around 5%  plus economic uncertainty equals shoppers trading down, seeking promotions, cutting waste and sticking to a budget. All of which gives a headache to supermarket bosses.

They of course will be twisting their supplier thumbscrews ever tighter, but ultimately there is only so far that cost cutting will take a business. At some stage it needs to grow. And here is where a sound own brand strategy can make a difference.
Own brand is possibly the best weapon in a supermarket’s armoury, if it gets it right.
It is supremely flexible. The name can be applied to thousands of products at various price ranges. Tesco Finest operates at the top end, and Tesco Value at the bottom. Sainsbury has Taste the Difference and Basics,  Asda has Extra Special, Chosen by You and Smart Price. Waitrose Essentials distinguishes their standard range from more expensive variants.

Done well own brands can enhance a retailers reputation, and provide a point of difference from competitors. Marks and Spencer has built a business on great quality, highly innovative food products.
Ultimately though, the reason why supermarkets make such an effort on own brands is that they are  more profitable than national brands, because they deliver a higher margin.

A good own brand range is especially important just now. Lower margin national brands are promoting heavily, drawing sales from own label. And, supermarkets are desperate to provide reasons for people to choose their store rather than a competitor’s, so that they get the highest possible share of a shrinking market.
So, we hear that Morrisons, which has 45% of its sales in own brand, is planning its first own label revamp for four years. Sainsbury is relaunching its 6500 line mid tier range, renaming it “By Sainsbury”.  Apparently around 25% of products across Sainsbury are new each year, so that customers don’t get bored and go elsewhere.

Waitrose is also working on improving its own label offer.

Reportedly Tesco is trying something completely different, registering a number of different brand names, but not displaying on the packaging that the brands in question belong to them.  The products will be premium priced. Chokablok ice cream for example which is said to be one of the new Tesco brands, sells at the same price as Haagen Daz.

The consistent theme through all these upgrades is an emphasis on quality. Supermarkets realise that in order for their own label ranges to succeed competitively they have to offer a combination of quality, price, and something a bit out of the ordinary.

So supermarkets’ own brands are more profitable and a potential differentiator. There is also a new thread emerging. Shopping online has been earmarked as a growth area,  and retailer labels can play a part in enhancing a supermarket’s on line shopping offer. The IGD points out that the web does not suffer the same space constraints as a shop, and so the full range of own label can be highlighted, reinforcing a stores reputation in whatever area they choose be it for innovation, price or quality, or ethical and environmental standards.








Sunday, 4 April 2010

Local Foods – From Niche to Mainstream in 5 Years

In early 2005, the local food movement was mostly confined to farmers markets, a few intrepid souls selling by mail order or over the internet, one or two up market shops sufficiently different to flourish despite the supermarkets, and funnily enough, ASDA who had just begun to experiment with local foods in its Kendal store.

Now local foods are a feature of every supermarket’s business. ASDA has gone from strength to strength, and now asks its shoppers to write in with suggestions for local foods they want stocked. Tesco says they sold £624 million worth of local foods in 2009, around 2.2% of its sales, and a 30% increase since 2007. Morrisons make a big thing of sourcing local products such as pies, unusual cheeses and the monthly guest ale. Smaller stores are benefitting too, and shopper interest in local foods has played a part in encouraging specialised shops to return to the high street.

Recent IGD research has found that 30% of people purchased locally produced food in the last month, up from just 15% in 2006. This compares with 17% buying organic, also up from 15% in 2006.

This rapid growth comes about because people have a very clear idea about why they buy local food.

The number 1 reason for buying local is freshness. 57% of shoppers perceive local food to be fresher because it has not travelled very far. 54% buy because of a wish to support local producers. About a third buy local because they wish to support local retailers. Other reasons for buying local are environment, naturalness, and the security of knowing where the food has come from and how it has been produced.

The growth will continue. This is a trend, not a fad.

Consumers clearly like the idea of buying local. It is an easy purchase, particularly if prices are similar to a non local version, which is nearly always the case in supermarkets, and will probably need to be in smaller shops unless they are offering something very special.

One challenge is to pin down exactly what local means to consumers in terms of geography. IGD research tells us that in Scotland and Wales, “local” is seen to be from that country. In England, according to some work done by the Food Standards Agency, the definition tends to be based either on mileage (which can be anywhere from 10 miles if a country dweller, to 100 if living in London), or on counties around where the person lives. My view would be that whatever the definition, it is important that consumers don’t feel cheated by a local claim.

It is also important to avoid thinking that being local is either a substitute for strong branding or a passport to a premium price. This is especially true if selling to supermarkets.

The final comment would be that a move from niche to mainstream almost always means a move from high to lower prices.

Thursday, 25 February 2010

Shopper Buying Behaviour - Insights from the NFU Conference

Edward Garner of Kantar Worldpanel ( previously called TNS) spoke yesterday about whether recent events like the move away from discounters, a decline in sales of value ranges, the resurgence of Waitrose and a swing to buying premium food over Christmas heralded the end of recessionary food buying behaviour. He did not offer a conclusion but en route to a fence sitting finale he did offer interesting nuggets about shoppers and the way they buy from the major supermarkets.

ASDA
The main message here is that ASDA is all about lowest price. When questioned, the overwhelming reason consumers give for shopping at ASDA is low prices., and it is ASDA who has gained most from the trend away from discounters. ASDA’s most recent price wheeze is to sell at a “round pound” price point, and in the last 12 weeks items priced at £1 have accounted for 14% of all sales. The round pound price point extends to £2, £3, £4 etc, and in total accounted for 22% of sales. Suppliers are being encouraged to tailor their products to sell at these particular prices.

The other side of the coin is that ASDA are not rated highly on quality. They undertrade on fresh and chilled foods, meaning their share of these is less than their total share, sales of their premium range are falling, and their organic sales are down 25% in the last twelve weeks, the worst performance of all supermarkets. (Note that ASDA would argue that they have upgraded quality and won lots of awards, but the Worldpanel figures suggest shoppers are not on the same page.)

Edward Garner did not say, but this obsession with price, coupled with a slight share decline over Christmas, may explain why Andy Bond who runs ASDA took the odd step of doing a public video in which he lambasted suppliers for not reducing prices when costs fell back , preferring instead to offer promotions which he termed “Weapons of Mass Distraction”. Bond declared that ASDA would “return with force” to its “Every day Low Price Strategy”, which he believes is best for customers, suppliers and shareholders. Other supermarkets might disagree.

Morrisons
Morrisons tends to be lumped with ASDA as a low price store, and certainly is seen by customers as offering good value, but it is changing its image and performing well. Morrisons overtrades by 3% in fresh and chilled foods, and by a huge 14% in fresh meat. As Garner says, something for farmers to be aware of. Also Morrisons is growing its number of wealthier customers, classed AB’s, who generally have more spending power.

Tesco
The news here is that their premium range is growing, and their discount range, introduced to fight Aldi and Lidl, only accounts for 1% of sales. Apparently the claim to be Britain’s biggest discounter backfired as we shoppers do not like to be told that we are buying cheap goods.

Waitrose
Waitrose has been doing well as shoppers get over the shock of inflationary price rises. Essentials, which Garner stressed is not a value range, but rather a communication exercise designed to make shoppers re- evaluate the store, has helped.

Marks and Spencer
Still a big problem, due to a lack of regular customers.

Fair Trade, Organics, Local Foods, and High Welfare
Sainsbury remains the biggest seller of Fair Trade products, and Waitrose sells 4.5 times more organic produce than its market share. However organic food has still not regained its position and Garner feels that the term organic will become a statement of production rather than a prime reason to buy.

Local Food sales are booming, and supermarkets are increasing the shelf space devoted to them.

High welfare products also continue to grow. 60% of all eggs sold in retail are now free range, despite costing about 30% more to buy, and free range chicken sales are also growing albeit at a slower rate.

Garner ended by saying that many industry watchers feel recessionary food buying habits may not have gone away because tax rises and spending cuts will breed uncertainty. On the other hand, he said, food only accounts for about 8% of overall consumer spend and so may not be the first port of call for consumer cutbacks.

If asked to come down on one side or the other, I’d say that there will be no return to unthinking spending any time soon, that people will pay for what they value whether it be premium ingredients or ethical beliefs, and not just follow lowest price, and that poor quality will not be tolerated.

Thursday, 8 October 2009

What Do Recent Results and Comments From the Big Four Supermarkets Tell Us About the Consumer?


Few know more about consumers than bosses of the big four supermarkets. Each day they scan data from the checkouts to see what is selling and what isn’t. Those with loyalty cards analyse how different types of consumer are spending their money. Tesco alone tracks the shopping behaviour of 16 million Clubcard holders. So, when the bosses speak its worth listening to how they see consumer trends.

The last twelve weeks saw Morrisons grow fastest at + 7.4%, hotly followed by ASDA at +7.2%. Sainsbury grew by 5.4%, and Tesco by 3.1%. However Tesco reckons that in recent weeks it has grown faster than the others due to offering double points on its Clubcard. (A point dismissed by Sainsbury as a “throwaway remark” not backed by figures.)

Where all four supermarket bosses are agreed is that food inflation has receded, growth rates are slowing, the battle for market share will intensify, and the focus will be on building customer loyalty.

There is agreement too that consumers are loosening their purse strings, albeit slightly. Both Tesco and Sainsbury reported higher sales of organic food and premium produce like Sainsbury’s Taste The Difference range and Tesco’s Finest. They said sales of ready meals are up after a long period of decline. Sainsbury said that sales of welfare friendly Freedom Foods have grown by 130%. At the other end of the scale, both said their lower price ranges were doing well, with Tesco very pleased with sales of their discount range, and Sainsbury’s Basics range having grown by 30%.

There is less concensus among the bosses about consumer confidence over the next few months. Terry Leahy of Tesco has called the bottom of the recession “We are past the low point and things are getting better in the UK. People feel their finances are under control”.

Justin King of Sainsbury is more gloomy. He sees increased VAT, increased taxes, interest rate rises and continued fear of unemployment as likely to put a damper on consumer spending, and that the current rate of promotions, which account for a third of sales compared with around a quarter historically, will need to continue. Andy bond of ASDA agrees - “Many of our customers are still cautious”, and will continue to search for the everyday low prices offered by ASDA.

King and Bond may be closer to the truth than Leahy. The National Consumer Confidence Index, published monthly by TNS (the market research company) does indeed confirm that consumers are a bit more positive about the economy. The improvement is marginal though. Whilst 72% of those interviewed think their household income next year will stay about the same as now, 71% think there will be less jobs available over the next 6 months, and 72% feel bad about the economy generally. Only 34% think the economy will be better in 6 months.

Its encouraging to see even tiny tips of green shoots. But there is no sign yet of a wholesale abandonment of thrift from the majority of consumers.
















Thursday, 23 April 2009

The Rise and Rise of the Packed Lunch, and a Chilling Comment from Tesco


In another example of people rapidly changing behaviour to save money, we learn from TNS, the market research company, that 28million of us ate a total of 4.2 billion packed lunches in the last twelve months. That's a growth of 6%, or 226 million more lunches.


Making your own sarnies is definitely a lower cost option, with an average spend per lunch box of £1.30p. Each box contains an average of 3.4 items, being the sandwiches, and a combination of a drink, packet of crisps and a sweet treat. Sometimes a piece of fruit is added, but usually alongside the treat as opposed to a replacement for it.


Packed lunches are now a way of life for those in the workplace, particularly young adults, as well as for schoolchildren. But we are generally quite conservative about what goes into the sandwiches. 69% of us stick to the same two types of filling, and cheese and ham remain the most popular.


There are two other lunch box trends which reflect the drive to cut costs. Alot more leftovers are being used, like pasta, and rice to make the lunch more filling. And there is less of a drive to include healthy products, which tend to be more expensive and less substantial.


TNS does not say this but the fact that so many more packed lunches were eaten during the coldest winter for decades when most bodies would be crying out for warm nourishment, highlights the efforts people will make to balance budgets.


TESCO


Much has been written about Tesco's annual results with most commentators rightly finding much to admire, despite the business losing market share. However, analysts will soon knock the company if share loss continues, and Tesco itself will be smarting from being second best to competitors. The following statement from Sir Terry Leahy should produce a chill in the heart of every Tesco supplier:-

"In the coming year we expect to trade the business harder.....investing more in cutting prices, sharpening promotions, and putting even more affordable products on our shelves".


So the question is who will pay for the price reductions, and who is monitoring that Tesco trades fairly with all its suppliers as it delivers the promised price cuts. Another reason to support appointment of a supermarket watchdog with teeth.








Monday, 20 April 2009

Internet Grocery Shopping - How Big Will it Get?

This week saw another salvo in the internet grocery shopping war with Waitrose scrapping its delivery fee on orders over £50. MD of Waitrose Mark Price, interviewed on Sky News, reckons that online grocery shopping it could be worth £13bn, or 10% of food bought, and he is planning to grow Waitrose’s online sales from a current £70m to £300m in the next 4 years.

Mr. Price is not alone in planning a big future for online. Sainsbury’s delivers 90,000 online orders per week , has seen sales grow by 40% year on year, and has marked the area out as a development priority. Tesco in their 2008 annual report said sales had grown by 31%. ASDA recently revamped their website. Ocado, who are an online venture only, part owned by Waitrose, have committed to matching Tesco on the price of its prepacked products, meaning it often undercuts Waitrose in store prices. The bullish views about the future are supported by the IGD, who estimate that the market was worth £3.5bn in 2008 and will double in size to £7.1bn by 2013.

So what do we know about online grocery shopping now, and why might it grow?

At £3.5bn the market is still small, despite being available for at least 8 years. According to TNS the market research company, speaking at a recent Meat Outlook conference, online sales account for 2% of Tesco’s till roll, about 0.6% of ASDA’s, and about 0.5% of Sainsbury and Ocado.

TNS also tells us that the heaviest on line shoppers are those with children 0-4 years old, 6.5% of this age group shop online. The lightest shoppers are retirees, of whom just over 1% shop online. High earners, of whom 7% shop online, are over 4 times more likely to shop this way than lower income groups.

Again, these are small numbers, so in an age of increasing technological savvy, the presence in other sectors of tried and tested models such as Amazon, and the faster times that broadband presents, what might be stopping people from using the internet to grocery shop?

Well, its got a bit of a bad reputation for reliability of delivery service, and quality of products delivered. Consumer magazine “Which” did a small but widely reported survey at the end of 2007 which said that online groceries arrived with very short shelf lives, less than those to be found in store. More recently, Mumsnet, the social site for mothers with young children, gives real life examples of the issues, showing a thread from last month where mums talked about banana yoghurts being substituted for bananas, wilting fruit and veg, and deliveries not turning up when promised. These mums concluded that the quality of experience varied a lot not just between different supermarkets, but from different stores within the same supermarket.


At the other end of the scale, IGD did some research with over 60’s and found that they would use the internet more if the sites were easier to navigate around, security could be guaranteed, quality would be consistent, prices were equal to those in store, delivery charges reduced, and the sites made easier to navigate around.

On the subject of growth potential, it is clear that supermarkets are working to address the issues, particularly making the sites more user friendly. Tesco’s idea of drawing attention to a cheaper version of what might first be selected is a great one, and far easier than walking up and down the shelves looking for the best buy. Sainsbury’s offers hundreds of recipes and allows you to buy all the necessary ingredients with just a click. The supermarkets are also making sure that there is no price disadvantage to shopping on line.

One key challenge for them all is to communicate more clearly and consistently the benefits of online shopping, particularly to key target groups such as mothers who must find it a struggle to organise all the paraphernalia needed to go shopping with a young child, and to older groups who may welcome the benefits such as having heavy shopping delivered to the door. Interestingly many of the Mumsnet mums were so committed to the benefits of online that they were prepared to shop around until they found a store they could rely on. But not everybody will be prepared to do this, so the other key challenge for supermarkets is to ensure total consistency, making every online shopping experience a good one.

Solve both of these and online could easily achieve 10% of all food buying.

Thursday, 4 December 2008

Tesco Outgunned by the Competition - Some Reasons Why

So Tesco is getting outgunned by the competition. Third quarter results show their sales up by a miserable 2% compared with Sainsbury up 4.3%, ASDA up 6.9% and Morrisons up 8.1%.

The root cause is customer defection. An analysis by TNS the market research company, shows that in the 12 weeks to November, Tesco lost about £22 million of business to ASDA, a further £10million ALDI and just under £10million to Morrisons . Clearly "every little helps" is not helping enough. Why might this be?

There seem to be three reasons.

First, Tesco has a muddled consumer message compared with competitors. ASDA and Morrisons are known as value supermarkets. ALDI screams rock bottom prices. Sainsbury have stuck with a quality message. Tesco by contrast have responded to the economic downturn by adding a number of discount type products similar to those sold by ALDI and the like, but done little with their main ranges. So in the shopper's mind they are offering neither the cheap prices of an ALDI, or consistent value across everything in store like ASDA and Morrisons. And a slogan like "every little helps" means little to cash strapped consumers keen to hit a budget but reluctant to buy rubbish.

Tesco's prices are too high, and their quality too low. How do we know this? Just read the comments left by shoppers on newspaper articles about Tesco's performance. They tell of huge price hikes, inconsistent prices from week to week, promotions advertised but no product available in store to buy, and inferior fresh products such as bakery and fruit and veg.

And most telling of all, Tesco seems to have forgotten about putting customers first. Customers are outraged at Tesco's arrogant attitude and lack of service.

I'd also add that resentment about the way they treat suppliers is reaching boiling point. At the moment lack of facts means their alleged practices tend not to hit the headlines. This will change if Tesco is demonstrated to cross the line between tough negotiation and outright intimidation, and the publicity will do them little good.

There are lessons for all businesses from the Tesco story.

Successful businesses have a very clear marketing message, and they stick with it. Their actual product offer is often fine tuned, but they do not stray from their basic core principles. And they never, ever, take their customers for granted.

No one would bet against Tesco which is one of the most succesful businesses in Britain. Despite a slowdown in sales they remain almost twice as big as their nearest competitor, and their discount range is turning over about £1billion, which is nearly the same as ALDI's total sales. But they are not invincible, and if they don't learn the lessons then their performance will struggle.






Tuesday, 25 November 2008

What Tesco Think About Local Foods


Boy, do Tesco tell it like it is.

Alistair Robinson,Senior Buying Manager buyer for the North of England, addressed the Institute of Agricultural Managers conference last week. His topic was "Local Foods Opportunities with Supermarkets".

Here's what Alistair said.

First up, consumers are still hugely enthusiastic about buying local foods, seeing them as fresher, of better quality, and helping to support local businesses and farmers. Tesco's customers want to buy local foods so Tesco is providing them.

Alistair explained what local means to the public. Although more consumers like to buy British, a British label on its own does not mean local. In Scotland and Wales, local means "from my country". In England, local means "from my county". It seems that the more specific a product is about its origin, the more the consumer feels that it will be top quality.

And people want a local option in most of the products they buy. Locally sourced fresh meat and veg, milk and cheeses, cakes and bread, and even ales and beers are all welcomed.

Tesco has seen some stunning local success stories."Black Country Pork Scratchings" from the Midlands outsells the national equivalent by 2 to 1. Yorkshire carrots sell 30% more than standard carrots, Cornish potatoes 12% more, and Warwickshire Spring Onions 5% more than an ordinary spring onion.

But here's the rub.

There's no premium in local foods, according to Tesco. Those great sales figures have been achieved by selling local food at a similar price to the standard variant. Basically, Tesco are looking to make the best use of every inch of shelf space, so all products have to sell at the highest possible volume,so this means in Tesco that they have to be on shelf at a competitive price, AND they have to deliver the same profit margin to Tesco as a standard version.

A brave soul at the conference asked whether, if consumers were so keen to buy local, Tesco should consider taking a lower margin, particularly as the whole point of local is that producers are small and so without economies of scale. Absolutely not said Alistair, for to sell something at a lower margin was a flawed business model, was totally unsustainable, and would only result in lost profit to Tesco, which is just not acceptable.

So there you have it. Tesco are very happy to support local foods as long as their customers want them, and as long as they make as much money for Tesco as anything else. At the first hint that consumers might be less enthusiastic about local foods, Tesco will walk away from them.

All this raises the question of whether its just Tesco local foods that cannot command a premium or the local foods sector in general.

According to a recent note from the IGD, consumers do see local foods as high priced. 61% say that price is a barrier to buying local and 43% think local food is too expensive. The IGD's advice is that local food producers and suppliers should review their promotional strategies, and offer competitively priced products in sectors that offer potential for growth.

If the objective is big volumes, then it seems Tesco have got their local food pricing policy right. The alternative strategy for producers is to stay away from the supermarkets, and target a smaller, niche market, possibly with a "local plus" message, in other words local with an extra consumer benefit.

As for the margin issue, Tesco will squeeze hard, and possibly harder than others. The key is for producers to walk into any deal with their eyes wide open.

Monday, 17 November 2008

Trends at Sainsbury - Justin King Speaks of Consumers, Farmers and Buying British


The conference and lecture season is in full swing and a few days ago Justin King, Chief Executive of Sainsbury spoke at the Royal Agriculture College's annual Bledisloe lecture. Smooth shaven, hair slicked back, immaculately suited and lightly tanned even in November, King could not have presented a greater contrast to last week's profiled speaker, John Torode. But in common with John he delivered an excellent session.

Justin King's main messages were these:

Value is increasingly important to Sainsbury shoppers. Own brand sales are booming due, he feels, to offering outstanding quality at a price well below the branded equivalent. Own brand now account for 51% of all the products they sell. The Basics range is also growing fast. People are cooking more from scratch. In an interesting twinning of the two, he said that free recipe cards, which have been around for three years, had really taken off when they had a value message like "Feed your family for a fiver" and "Love your leftovers".

Despite tough times though, consumers are not prepared to go back on their principles, rather they want "value, but not at the expense of values". King cited Sainsbury sales of higher welfare chicken, which now account for 33% of all chicken sold compared with 14% in 2006. And sales have accelerated, even as the credit crunch bites harder. Free range egg sales also continue to grow. Apparently animal welfare issues are the second highest in his postbag, the top issue being palm oil and concerns about destruction of the rain forests and the creatures who dwell there.

The premium market continues to grow, but not all bits of it. Fair Trade still sells well, as does food with higher quality ingredients, and higher welfare products. But organic is struggling, in King's view because consumers are increasingly questioning whether the premium charged is justified, and because the sector has "lost sight of its roots", straying away from core basic foods into fringe activities.

Mindful of his audience and its farming connections, Justin King devoted a section of his speech to British farming.

Justin King had a blunt message to farmers. Basically, there are still too many substandard operators who drag the returns down for everyone else. On the plus side, Sainsbury are prepared to pay a premium to farmers who deliver certain standards, this is the case on milk now, and they are working on a similar scheme for beef and sheep.

He feels British farmers are still too production focussed, and not concerned enough about consumers and what they want. Whilst consumers do like to buy British when it represents the best in quality and freshness, they are very happy to buy from abroad, especially from the developing world. In a nutshell, Sainsbury has no intention of confining itself to purchasing only British food.

A few days after the lecture, Sainsbury posted a good set of financial results for the first half of 2008. Recent TNS market research data showed their market share to be holding up pretty well against the onslaught from the cheaper end of the grocery trade, and doing better than Tesco. Sainsbury seems to be steering a sound course through difficult times.



Monday, 20 October 2008

Unthinking Consumerism - R.I.P




It looks as if the days of "I want what I want when I want it" are over, even for the relatively affluent, and even when it comes to food which still only accounts for about 10% of UK consumer expenditure. Shoppers are planning more carefully, shopping more wisely, and weighing up the quality/price equation more thoughtfully.
Consider what we know.
Latest research from the Institute of Grocery Distribution (The Credit Crunch-Adapting to Change) shows that 16% more of us are planning meals, 13% more are cooking smaller portions, and 6% more are cooking with leftovers. Indeed the research found that 59% are actively economising.
We also know that shoppers are seeking bargains. The ALDI phenomenon is well documented, as is the growth in shoppers visiting Morrisons and ASDA. Tesco is now promoting itself as the UK's biggest discounter, which makes sense given that it is still 10 times the size of ALDI. Sainsbury claims a growth of 30% in their Basics range and a big uptake in their own label products which sell about 20% cheaper than the equivalent brand. Waitrose says that 30% more products are being bought on promotion. Certainly in the red meat market there is ample evidence of careful buying, with less being bought on each shopping trip, and much more thought being given to the relative price of the various meats. For example lamb, which has seen a huge drop in sales this year, has suddenly bounced back because it has become much closer in price to beef.
It does look though as if consumers have not turned their backs completely on premium tier foods. Sainsbury's Taste the Difference range is growing, albeit modestly, and is still 3 to 4 times the size of its Basics range. Waitrose says that it As Good as Eating Out products have grown by 40%, and that it is "still selling alot of organic".
Which leads to the often raised question of whether ethics have gone out of the window in favour of cheapness. Joanne Denney Finch of IGD, presenting their research findings said ethical purchasing is still important, and that that 79% of people are "still engaged in purchasing some type of ethical product", be it organic, Fair Trade or local produce. And it seems as if as many people as ever are visiting farmers markets. My guess would be that there is still a core of committed people who feel strongly about a particular issue, and continue to buy, but that fringe purchasers who were perhaps following a trend rather than a principle have dropped out completely.
What all this points to is that consumers are being much more thoughtful about how they buy food. Now it's "two stop shopping" for value instead of one stop for convenience. Its being much more canny about promotional offers. And its being much more marketing savvy. Consumers are twigging that the salmon in a store's best range is actually the same as in the basic product, but it's just uniformly presented, and so costs up to 50% more. The label on the premium mince might be classier, but it's still mince. The cooking apples, carrots and parsnips in the cheaper range might be all sorts of odd sizes, but they still taste the same as the more expensive version.
I can't see people reverting to unthinking consumerism any time soon. Yesterday's worry about petrol prices might have abated now that it's below a £ a litre, and the banks seem a bit less wobbly, but today the spectre of unemployment looms, and tomorrow it will be something else.
In this more discerning climate the winners will be those who truly understand what is important to consumers, and offer great quality at a price which consumers think is worth paying.












Friday, 12 September 2008

Food Buying Habits - How, When, and Why Did It All Change?


Food shopping habits have changed. Consumers are changing where they shop, how they shop, and what they buy.


Morrisons, home of low prices, and Waitrose at the premium end of the scale, both published half year results a couple of days ago. Morrisons grew like for like sales by 7.6%, (like for like meaning sales in stores open at least a year), and profits by 19%. Waitrose grew sales by 2.5%, a third of the rate of Morrisons, were forced to cut some prices to compete and hold market share, and saw profits fall by 8%. ALDI, viewed as having the cheapest prices of the lot, is now said to be growing sales at about 30% versus last year. A confident statement from ASDA a few weeks ago indicated that they are doing just fine because they offer really low prices. And Sainsbury and the once the once invulnerable Tesco are losing out.


Consumers are changing what they buy. We know that organic sales are struggling, reportedly down 20% in August versus last year, that meat consumption is down 5% according to the latest figures published on the British Pig Executive website, and DairyCo says that milk consumption is down. Consumers are also buying more products in retailer's Value ranges. Morrisons showed a chart at their results presentation illustrating that across the whole of the grocery trade Value ranges were growing at about 8% in the spring, but have now rocketed to a growth of nearly 30%. By contrast Premium ranges growth has fallen from a high of 15% in March 08 to around 3% in August.


Other startling changes are happening. Sainsbury tell us that between July and August sales of tupperware containers have grown by 36%, and sandwich bags by 35%, as more people take sandwiches to work instead of buying ready made.


All in all, it seems that beleaguered Brits are leaving no stone unturned in an effort to spend less. The interesting thing though, is that although the credit crunch started almost a year ago with the Northern Rock wobble, the big changes in what and where people buy only started in the spring. Going back to Waitrose as an example, they were sailing along quite nicely until early summer.


Why the drop since then? Because that's when consumer confidence started to plummet,worn away by headlines about food price inflation, spikes in oil prices, mortgage worries, and warnings of rising energy bills Another chart from Morrisons shows that in March, consumers confidence levels were down by 18%, in August they were down by 40%. Or to put it another way, nearly half the country thinks things are going to get worse, much worse. If they are that worried, it's no wonder people are changing behaviour, battening down the hatches, and bracing themselves for what might be around the next corner.


What is clear though, is that doom mongers who say they always knew that all people want is cheap food are wrong. Despite the belt tightening, Premium sales are still growing albeit at a slower rate than previously. It does not look either as if shoppers are ditching ethical principles altogether. Waitrose says that consumers are still supporting welfare friendly food but choosing free range rather than organic to save some money. ASDA says its sales of organic produce have grown by 25%, and Morrisons reported that their sales of both Fair Trade and organic sales are growing.


As ever, it does seem as if those who offer good quality combined with good value (which is not the same thing as price) will ride out the storm, ready for an upturn in confidence.

Monday, 11 August 2008

A Shift to Thrift - Organic Sales Well Down, Red Meat Not Far Behind

Whether its Gordon Brown telling us not to waste food, a general belt tightening in an effort to pay the bills, or more questioning of the value of what we buy, there is a definite change in consumer buying habits.

A well publicised example of the shift to thrift comes in the shape of Tesco's decision to reduce the price of many organic lines. Their press release quotes TNS saying that demand for organic produce across all retailers has dropped by 8.1% in the last three months. Tesco says that many people would like to buy organic but won't pay the premium. So it has cut the price of new potatoes and carrots by 20%, broccoli and asparagus by 25%,avocados by 13%, mixed peppers by 12%, leeks by 11% and courgettes by 5%.

Next, red meat. In the 12 weeks to June 15th, according to TNS figures published by the British Pig Executive, volume sales of beef, lamb and pork dropped by 4.7% in volume compared with last year. What seems to be happening is that fewer people are buying red meat on a regular basis, and those that do buy are buying smaller amounts. Worst hit is lamb, down 12%, followed by beef down 4% and pork down 1%. Lamb of course is the most expensive red meat, and pork the cheapest on a per kilo basis. Sausages are the only red meat product showing any growth, and then by only 1%. The shift to thrift is clear in the type of cuts bought, with a marked trend to minced and stewing beef and lamb, pork belly, and pork shoulder. On the other hand, sales of roasting joints are well down, and even convenient cuts like chops and steaks are selling less than last year.

The shift is happening in even the smartest places. Waitrose have reported a 55% increase in sales of free range chicken legs and thighs, compared with 10% for significantly dearer chicken breasts.

On dairy, the figures are less startling. DairyCo data for the year to July 2008 shows that liquid milk sales have started to fall back gradually, and are now at their lowest since September 2007. Its unlikely that people are using less milk, rather that they are being careful on date codes and throwing less away. All growth has gone from organic milk, possibly as consumers question the premium paid, and sales are now drifting slowly down.

On a brighter note, total cheese sales are up by 1%, but odd things are happening. The super-premium cheddar cheeses are forging ahead. At the other end of the scale, supermarkets' value cheddars are also growing. There is a trend to buying brands rather than own label cheeses, probably because the price difference between the two is now an average of 14p per kilo when a year ago it was 29p.

Some of the changes in what consumers buy are predictable, the drop in some organic sales for example, and the switch to brands when there is not much price difference with own label, and the move to buying cheaper cuts of meat.

But a nearly 5% decline in total red meat sales is alarming, and is the direct result of major price hikes in shops.

The next few months will be tricky for livestock. Consumer demand is falling, we are heading into a period of heavy supply, and seemingly the euro is weakening which could dampen export sales. As ever, supermarkets will be forcing the pace. The red meat market is important for them, and they will be evaluating their strategies carefully. Will they lower prices in their stores to boost sales, or keep prices up? Tesco's milk price reduction today probably shows the way. Prices will come down. But who will ultimately fund the fall? Hopefully the number crunchers at the NFU, DEFRA, EBLEX, BPEX and the livestock associations are keeping close tabs on the percentage of retail price going into farmgate prices. And will complain long and loudly if farmers are getting a worse deal.

Tuesday, 24 June 2008

Organic Market Outlook

The media's fascination with the organics market continues but this time with the focus on how it is faring during the credit crunch.
The question of how a sector which is still less than two percent of total food sales can command so many column inches will be tackled another day. The more pressing issue is whether organic farmers will find a ready market for their produce or will it have to be offloaded at conventional prices.
Here's a round up of the latest news on the state of the market.
Sky News commissioned a special piece of research, and found that total sales of organic produce had been growing until April when for the first time sales dropped below the previous year.
The Telegraph reported that sales of fruit and veg box schemes have fallen sharply. One supplier said that 10% of his customers had cancelled their order, and he reckoned that 20% would have cancelled by the year end. One firm has gone into administration.
Up at the Royal Highland Show, Andrew Gibson of Two Sisters Food Group said that sales of organic chicken had virtually disappeared, and that free range was not growing as fast as it had. The British Poultry Council says that sales of organic eggs are showing no growth year on year, although free range sales were still up.
DairyCo's latest data on the milk market shows flat organic milk sales.
No consumer sales figures have been reported for beef or lamb.
The reason for the slowdown/declines in sales seem firmly to do with price. One Abel and Cole box scheme customer, interviewed in the Telegraph said "I'm afraid the organic box is a bit of an unaffordable luxury"; and another said "It was a luxury, but we never used it up each week. I have no regrets at all that we cancelled." A new mother interviewed by Sky also said that it was price which had made her turn away from organics, especially packaged food.
All of which looks a bit gloomy.
By contrast though ASDA reckons that organics are one of their fastest growing areas, and they plan to add new organic lines this year, Tesco reported that the growth rate for total organic sales had slowed to about 10%, which is not bad, even though it compares with about 30% in previous years, and Sainsbury that organic sales were one of their major growth areas. Grampian Country Foods have said they want to increase organic chicken production from 15,000 birds annnually to 20,000 (and double free range production to 90,000 birds). The Soil Association is projecting sales growth of 10% in 2008, and Nic Lampkin, an academic expert on Welsh organics said in the Western Mail that " There is still room for some growth".
It does look as if the rate of sales growth for organic food will slow whilst the current financial climate continues, which is what we predicted at the start of the year.
Could sales actually decline? Lampkin points out that 80% of organic sales are made to just 20% of all those who buy organic, and he thinks those customers will stay loyal because they buy for reasons of principle. However, should there be a wholesale walking away by the other 80% of consumers then clearly sales will fall substantially. Trying to decide if organics are worth the money is made more tricky by groups such as Which saying that their taste tests showed no difference between standard and organic products, strawberries being cited.
The overall conclusion though is that sales growth will continue in the major supermarkets who want to promote higher priced food like organics, but who will work hard to reduce the differential between organic and conventional food to ensure that consumers will trade up and not be put off by an overly big organic premium.
The outlook for those outside of the supermarket food chain looks bleaker unless they too can reduce the difference in price. At the moment some of the price differences are steep to put it mildly. The Telegraph quotes prices from an Abel and Cole box versus the same items bought from Tesco's organic section. Jersey Royal potatoes are £7.00 a kilo from Abel and Cole compared with £1.99 from Tesco, cherry tomatoes £10 a kilo versus £2.46, Little Gem lettuce £2.18 versus 50p, and even the humble onion at £1.66 a kilo compared with 84p. There's got to alot of added value to justify those differences, and for many thay value just is not there.
As far as action is concerned, organic farmers will of course need to watch costs carefully. Those contemplating a move to organic farming should take a very close look indeed at the overall cost of organic production versus conventional, and be absolutely sure that are still better off even if current premiums are reduced. They should also investigate what is happening to the market for their particular product, as not all organic sectors will perform in the same way.

Friday, 30 May 2008

Supermarket Sales Show Strong Growth, No Sign of Consumer Cutbacks

Taylor Nelson Sofres (TNS) has published grocery sales growth and market share figures for the 12 weeks to May 16th. They show no signs of a consumer cutback. Total sales are up 6.6%, with big share gains for Morrisons (sales up 8.7%) and ASDA (up 7.6%) at the expense of Sainsbury (up 4.6%) and Tesco (up 6%). Somerfield and the Coop continue to lose share, and independent stores are holding up well.

The much talked about growth in sales through cheaper priced discount stores seems to be more about shoppers at the now defunct Kwiksave seeking a similar type of store rather than a consumer flight to cheaper shopping. The total market share held by discounters last year was 5.7% and it is still 5.7% . At the other end of the scale, up market Waitrose held a 3.9% share both last year and this, indicating that consumers are still buying premium food. Overall, the only hint of a change is a small share growth for Iceland which sells lower priced frozen food.
The actual share numbers for 2008, with 2007 in brackets, are as follows:
%
Tesco 31.1 (31.3)

Asda 16.9 (16.7)

Sainsbury 16.0 (16.3)

Morrisons 11.4 (11.2)

Somerfield 3.7 (3.8)

Kwiksave 0.0 (0.2)

Waitrose 3.9 (3.9)

Iceland 1.7 (1.6)

Netto 0.6 (0.7)

Lidl 2.3 (2.3)

Aldi 2.8 (2.3)

Co-ops 4.5 4.3

Other Multiples 1.6 1.7

Independents 2.8 2.8

Wednesday, 14 May 2008

Food Inflation - Consumer Behaviour, Supermarket Reaction, Farm Gate Price Fights Ahead

There's been a raft of data published in the last few days covering April's inflation numbers, consumer research from the levy boards, and supermarket performance in the first quarter of the year. Four messages come singing out and these are:

1. Annual food inflation at 6.6% (Retail Price Index) is indeed higher than consumers have been used to recently, but despite the increases food remains a small proportion of household spend.
2. There is little sign of consumers spending less, or of any flight from premium quality food.
3. Supermarkets are keeping price inflation well below published figures because of heavy price promotions.
4. There's an almighty battle ahead on farmgate prices as supermarkets fight ferociously to keep prices low and stop consumer defections to a rival store.

Food Inflation
The rate of inflation varies by sector. Bread and cereal suppliers continue to rack up prices, as do egg producers. By contrast, after a run of monthly increases dairy prices are now dropping compared with March. The biggest change is red meat pricing which has shown price rises in April of 7.2% for pork, 4.2% for beef, and 5% for home produced lamb. All connected to the industry need to remember that until the last couple of months beef and lamb prices were dropping, and that these rises are a much needed correction to help farmers recover their input costs.

Consumer purchases
There is no evidence of a downturn in consumer purchasing of basic products. As reported in May 5th's blog, liquid milk sales have dropped very slightly, but Taylor Nelson Sofres data, published by the British Pig Executive (BPEX), shows volume sales of beef for January to March up 3%, lamb up 4%, and pork up 10%. Neither are consumers trading down to cheaper cuts of meat.
Indeed, the trend to buying top quality food is not just continuing but actually accelerating. Morrisons have said that sales of their value range are up 13%, but it's premium ranges have grown by 22%. ASDA have said their total food range grew by 6.4% in the first three months of 2008, but their premium lines are up 30%. Sainsbury's have said they reckon that quality food is resilient in when the economy is sluggish, in their view because people eat out of home less often. Latest figures show that Waitrose, purveyor of top quality and fairly expensive food is holding market share. The only sign of slowing down is organics, according to the Guardian, where growth is 10% year on year compared with about 30% recently. But 10% is still healthy.
The only sign of consumers being price conscious is that discount stores who sell at rock bottom prices, such as Netto, Lidl, and Aldi are gaining market share, which could signal more willingness on consumers part to seek the best price for basics, but on the other hand, the share gain could be due to consumers who used to shop in the now defunct Kwiksave turning to a similar type of shopping outlet.

The big issue
The big issue is not whether food inflation will stop consumers buying. Rather, its the declared intent of the major supermarkets to keep prices low. Tesco last week announced 1000 price related promotions. Justin King of Sainsbury yesterday said he reckoned inflation was nearer 2% because of the steps big grocers have taken to keep prices down. King saw this fight for low prices continuing because of the competition between them. Andy Bond of ASDA is at this square also. His results statement yesterday ended with the words "We have a duty to lock down inflation by working with our suppliers to cut costs to ensure that our customers are always getting the best possible deal on their weekly shopping."

A pricing battle seems inevitable, and its difficult to see how farmer producers can remain unaffected. Three things need to be regularly and widely communicated, particularly as prices to livestock and dairy farmers are on the rise. The first point is that prices might be rising now but they have been unprecedentedly low for years. Secondly, input prices are rocketing and must be recovered, and thirdly, farm incomes still remain too low to be viable at a time when the country should be producing more to ensure food security.