Showing posts with label ethical purchasing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ethical purchasing. Show all posts

Sunday, 8 May 2011

Consumer Purchases of "Ethical" Foods - Some Data from DEFRA


It is difficult to get a factual grip on the difference between what consumers say they will do and what they actually do when buying food. DEFRA has had a stab at this as part of their effort to build a sustainable food chain.
Their research confirms that consumers are interested in the issues surrounding sustainable food production, but that actual purchase of some foods generally defined as ethical remains fairly low.
Free range eggs
This is the animal welfare issue that has gained most support. 50% of those who think animal welfare is important buy free range eggs - but only a third of them buy free range all the time, and at the other end of the spectrum, 31% buy free range less than 10% of the time.
Free range chicken
88% of households buy free range chicken less than 10% of the time, and 75% never buy free range at all. DEFRA does not report purchase of higher welfare chicken where sales have grown rapidly, and so the numbers may underplay consumer committment to welfare.
Fair Trade tea and coffee
This is another sector which has received wide publicity, but 93% of households buy fair trade coffee less than 10% of the time, with the equivalent figure for tea being 85%.
British apples in season
Despite growing enthusiasm for local produce, 62% of households buy British apples in season less than 10% of the time.
Green issues
The DEFRA research does not give buying figures for environmentally friendly products, but does give clues about peoples' feelings on the subject. In general, people are aware of the issues but stop short of agreeing with inconvenient or financially disadvantageous measures to limit environmental damage. So, whilst 82% agree that people have a duty to recycle, only 13% feel car owners should pay higher taxes to offset the environmental damage they do, and just 8% strongly agree that people who fly should bear the cost of environmental damage.
The DEFRA research paints a picture of informed consumers, who say they are actively seeking sustainable or ethical foods, but who are not yet wholly committed to buying them.
It serves as a timely reminder that, for most people, making the leap from being informed and interested to embracing a wholesale change in buying behaviour takes a very long time.

Wednesday, 8 December 2010

The Demanding Consumer - Wanting it All and Wanting it Now

Consumers are fickle creatures. What they want changes all the time.

The Institute of Grocery Distribution signalled a change in consumer behaviour when they found that exemplary ethics are increasingly expected as the normal way of doing business. No longer, they say, are value seekers and ethical consumers two different groups. Rather, there is an increasing overlap between the two. Consumers are “seeking value for their values” and are not prepared to pay a big premium for high ethical standards.

Another example of change comes from consultants OC&C. They suggest that the days have gone of retailers being known for one particular attribute, like low prices, or great service, or widest choice. Instead, they say, consumers are no longer prepared to make tradeoffs, like swapping price for service, or service for choice, or sacrificing all for the cheapest price.

These changes are not limited to a few consumers. The demanding consumer is everywhere, and we see evidence of retailers rushing to satisfy these demands in store right now.

Waitrose is a great example. Known primarily for its good quality and service, but considered expensive, it has now matched Tesco’s price on 1000 lines, and regularly price promotes its products.

Sainsbury also listens hard to consumers. It too price promotes heavily, it has developed its own Sainsbury brand range to provide cheaper alternatives to major national brands, but it offers a premium range for quality seekers.

ASDA has recently said its food is not of good enough quality, and upped its game with the introduction of “Chosen by You”.

As to why consumers have become even fussier, OC&C reckon that the internet has been a factor, for, at the click of a mouse, consumers see huge choice, at the best possible price, backed by great service, like next day delivery and no hassle returns.

The economic downturn will have played a part too, with consumers understandably wanting to get the best possible value for money, meaning they will search for the combination of price, choice, quality and service that best suits their particular needs.

Probably the major reason for consumers wanting it all and wanting it now is the nature of UK retailing. Grocers in particular are intensely competitive. They are obsessed with not allowing rivals to steal market share and so are highly attuned to the slightest nuance of consumer behaviour change. Their eagerness to respond before their rivals means that even slight hints of consumer change are put into action, to make sure shoppers stay with them as opposed to taking their custom elsewhere. And so consumers get used to having their demands met and understandably keep pushing for more.

Whatever the reasons, we can expect the bar of consumer demand to get ever higher.

Thursday, 25 February 2010

Shopper Buying Behaviour - Insights from the NFU Conference

Edward Garner of Kantar Worldpanel ( previously called TNS) spoke yesterday about whether recent events like the move away from discounters, a decline in sales of value ranges, the resurgence of Waitrose and a swing to buying premium food over Christmas heralded the end of recessionary food buying behaviour. He did not offer a conclusion but en route to a fence sitting finale he did offer interesting nuggets about shoppers and the way they buy from the major supermarkets.

ASDA
The main message here is that ASDA is all about lowest price. When questioned, the overwhelming reason consumers give for shopping at ASDA is low prices., and it is ASDA who has gained most from the trend away from discounters. ASDA’s most recent price wheeze is to sell at a “round pound” price point, and in the last 12 weeks items priced at £1 have accounted for 14% of all sales. The round pound price point extends to £2, £3, £4 etc, and in total accounted for 22% of sales. Suppliers are being encouraged to tailor their products to sell at these particular prices.

The other side of the coin is that ASDA are not rated highly on quality. They undertrade on fresh and chilled foods, meaning their share of these is less than their total share, sales of their premium range are falling, and their organic sales are down 25% in the last twelve weeks, the worst performance of all supermarkets. (Note that ASDA would argue that they have upgraded quality and won lots of awards, but the Worldpanel figures suggest shoppers are not on the same page.)

Edward Garner did not say, but this obsession with price, coupled with a slight share decline over Christmas, may explain why Andy Bond who runs ASDA took the odd step of doing a public video in which he lambasted suppliers for not reducing prices when costs fell back , preferring instead to offer promotions which he termed “Weapons of Mass Distraction”. Bond declared that ASDA would “return with force” to its “Every day Low Price Strategy”, which he believes is best for customers, suppliers and shareholders. Other supermarkets might disagree.

Morrisons
Morrisons tends to be lumped with ASDA as a low price store, and certainly is seen by customers as offering good value, but it is changing its image and performing well. Morrisons overtrades by 3% in fresh and chilled foods, and by a huge 14% in fresh meat. As Garner says, something for farmers to be aware of. Also Morrisons is growing its number of wealthier customers, classed AB’s, who generally have more spending power.

Tesco
The news here is that their premium range is growing, and their discount range, introduced to fight Aldi and Lidl, only accounts for 1% of sales. Apparently the claim to be Britain’s biggest discounter backfired as we shoppers do not like to be told that we are buying cheap goods.

Waitrose
Waitrose has been doing well as shoppers get over the shock of inflationary price rises. Essentials, which Garner stressed is not a value range, but rather a communication exercise designed to make shoppers re- evaluate the store, has helped.

Marks and Spencer
Still a big problem, due to a lack of regular customers.

Fair Trade, Organics, Local Foods, and High Welfare
Sainsbury remains the biggest seller of Fair Trade products, and Waitrose sells 4.5 times more organic produce than its market share. However organic food has still not regained its position and Garner feels that the term organic will become a statement of production rather than a prime reason to buy.

Local Food sales are booming, and supermarkets are increasing the shelf space devoted to them.

High welfare products also continue to grow. 60% of all eggs sold in retail are now free range, despite costing about 30% more to buy, and free range chicken sales are also growing albeit at a slower rate.

Garner ended by saying that many industry watchers feel recessionary food buying habits may not have gone away because tax rises and spending cuts will breed uncertainty. On the other hand, he said, food only accounts for about 8% of overall consumer spend and so may not be the first port of call for consumer cutbacks.

If asked to come down on one side or the other, I’d say that there will be no return to unthinking spending any time soon, that people will pay for what they value whether it be premium ingredients or ethical beliefs, and not just follow lowest price, and that poor quality will not be tolerated.

Monday, 6 April 2009

Consumers and the Credit Crunch - Latest Views on Food Buying Behaviour


In the words of Justin King of Sainsbury, speaking during a business performance update last week - “the consumer is in a bad place just now”. Which is not really surprising, given the amount of depressing economic news.

Nevertheless, both Sainsbury and Morrisons, who also gave a business update last week, feel that food is one of the last things where consumers are prepared to trade down. A view echoed by the IGD (Institute of Grocery Distribution) who say their research indicates that “Economising is not the same as down trading”. Sainsbury’s “Basics” range is indeed up 60% year on year, but it still accounts for only 3% of total sales. Sales of their premium “Taste the Difference” range are “off the pace”, which is corporate speak for falling, but the range is still 2.5x as big as Basics, and the sales decline is attributed to a drop in the market for ready meals, rather than a flight from quality. Morrisons “The Best” premium range is up by 5.3%
So there is still a search for good food, and a Times Populus survey (26th March) put quality as equal to value for money when it comes to choosing a store. But its not quality at any price. Instead, people are far pickier about what they buy and energetic about finding the best deals.

The search for good deals is leading to much shopping around. The days of convenient one stop shopping have given way to two and even three stop shopping and both Morrisons and Sainsbury claim an increase in numbers of shoppers in their stores. What this suggests is that the traditional way of categorising stores is dead. No longer can we say Sainsbury and Waitrose upmarket, ASDA and Morrisons downmarket, and Tesco in the middle. Its much more individual than that now with each shopper asking whether the quality /value equation at a particular store at a particular time is right for them. Looking at the crystal ball I’d say that the next big strategic challenge from supermarkets will be how to build loyalty. Meanwhile value offers will become increasingly innovative.

Once in the store, what the shopper buys is changing. The aforementioned ready meals market is plummeting, and TNS (Taylor Nelson Sofres) the market research company tells us that frozen foods are growing by over 9% year on year, enjoying a change in status from poor relation to a wise choice due to cheaper prices and far less waste.

The IGD as well as the supermarkets tell us that there’s a lot more cooking from scratch going on, apparently herbs and fresh pasta are flying off the shelves in Morrisons. And there is a return to families eating together.

There are mixed views about whether ethical purchasing is taking a back seat. The decline in the organic market has been reported to death (sales down 15% in the last three months, bread down 31%, vegetables down 10% according to TNS), but as is being acknowledged even by the Soil Association, the issue here is that consumers can’t get their heads around why organics in general are worth a premium. Animal welfare issues though remain important to consumers. Sainsbury stressed again last week that this is something shoppers search for, and IGD research confirms it. The question of course is where this welcome concern about animal welfare will go next and there are reports that Hugh Fearnley Whittingstall is turning his attention to dairy cattle.

So in summary, the recession is leading to changes in what and how shoppers buy. They are not prepared though to sacrifice quality, and will shop around to get it at the right price. Equally they are prepared to support ethical products where they clearly understand what it is that they are paying for.

Monday, 17 November 2008

Trends at Sainsbury - Justin King Speaks of Consumers, Farmers and Buying British


The conference and lecture season is in full swing and a few days ago Justin King, Chief Executive of Sainsbury spoke at the Royal Agriculture College's annual Bledisloe lecture. Smooth shaven, hair slicked back, immaculately suited and lightly tanned even in November, King could not have presented a greater contrast to last week's profiled speaker, John Torode. But in common with John he delivered an excellent session.

Justin King's main messages were these:

Value is increasingly important to Sainsbury shoppers. Own brand sales are booming due, he feels, to offering outstanding quality at a price well below the branded equivalent. Own brand now account for 51% of all the products they sell. The Basics range is also growing fast. People are cooking more from scratch. In an interesting twinning of the two, he said that free recipe cards, which have been around for three years, had really taken off when they had a value message like "Feed your family for a fiver" and "Love your leftovers".

Despite tough times though, consumers are not prepared to go back on their principles, rather they want "value, but not at the expense of values". King cited Sainsbury sales of higher welfare chicken, which now account for 33% of all chicken sold compared with 14% in 2006. And sales have accelerated, even as the credit crunch bites harder. Free range egg sales also continue to grow. Apparently animal welfare issues are the second highest in his postbag, the top issue being palm oil and concerns about destruction of the rain forests and the creatures who dwell there.

The premium market continues to grow, but not all bits of it. Fair Trade still sells well, as does food with higher quality ingredients, and higher welfare products. But organic is struggling, in King's view because consumers are increasingly questioning whether the premium charged is justified, and because the sector has "lost sight of its roots", straying away from core basic foods into fringe activities.

Mindful of his audience and its farming connections, Justin King devoted a section of his speech to British farming.

Justin King had a blunt message to farmers. Basically, there are still too many substandard operators who drag the returns down for everyone else. On the plus side, Sainsbury are prepared to pay a premium to farmers who deliver certain standards, this is the case on milk now, and they are working on a similar scheme for beef and sheep.

He feels British farmers are still too production focussed, and not concerned enough about consumers and what they want. Whilst consumers do like to buy British when it represents the best in quality and freshness, they are very happy to buy from abroad, especially from the developing world. In a nutshell, Sainsbury has no intention of confining itself to purchasing only British food.

A few days after the lecture, Sainsbury posted a good set of financial results for the first half of 2008. Recent TNS market research data showed their market share to be holding up pretty well against the onslaught from the cheaper end of the grocery trade, and doing better than Tesco. Sainsbury seems to be steering a sound course through difficult times.



Monday, 20 October 2008

Unthinking Consumerism - R.I.P




It looks as if the days of "I want what I want when I want it" are over, even for the relatively affluent, and even when it comes to food which still only accounts for about 10% of UK consumer expenditure. Shoppers are planning more carefully, shopping more wisely, and weighing up the quality/price equation more thoughtfully.
Consider what we know.
Latest research from the Institute of Grocery Distribution (The Credit Crunch-Adapting to Change) shows that 16% more of us are planning meals, 13% more are cooking smaller portions, and 6% more are cooking with leftovers. Indeed the research found that 59% are actively economising.
We also know that shoppers are seeking bargains. The ALDI phenomenon is well documented, as is the growth in shoppers visiting Morrisons and ASDA. Tesco is now promoting itself as the UK's biggest discounter, which makes sense given that it is still 10 times the size of ALDI. Sainsbury claims a growth of 30% in their Basics range and a big uptake in their own label products which sell about 20% cheaper than the equivalent brand. Waitrose says that 30% more products are being bought on promotion. Certainly in the red meat market there is ample evidence of careful buying, with less being bought on each shopping trip, and much more thought being given to the relative price of the various meats. For example lamb, which has seen a huge drop in sales this year, has suddenly bounced back because it has become much closer in price to beef.
It does look though as if consumers have not turned their backs completely on premium tier foods. Sainsbury's Taste the Difference range is growing, albeit modestly, and is still 3 to 4 times the size of its Basics range. Waitrose says that it As Good as Eating Out products have grown by 40%, and that it is "still selling alot of organic".
Which leads to the often raised question of whether ethics have gone out of the window in favour of cheapness. Joanne Denney Finch of IGD, presenting their research findings said ethical purchasing is still important, and that that 79% of people are "still engaged in purchasing some type of ethical product", be it organic, Fair Trade or local produce. And it seems as if as many people as ever are visiting farmers markets. My guess would be that there is still a core of committed people who feel strongly about a particular issue, and continue to buy, but that fringe purchasers who were perhaps following a trend rather than a principle have dropped out completely.
What all this points to is that consumers are being much more thoughtful about how they buy food. Now it's "two stop shopping" for value instead of one stop for convenience. Its being much more canny about promotional offers. And its being much more marketing savvy. Consumers are twigging that the salmon in a store's best range is actually the same as in the basic product, but it's just uniformly presented, and so costs up to 50% more. The label on the premium mince might be classier, but it's still mince. The cooking apples, carrots and parsnips in the cheaper range might be all sorts of odd sizes, but they still taste the same as the more expensive version.
I can't see people reverting to unthinking consumerism any time soon. Yesterday's worry about petrol prices might have abated now that it's below a £ a litre, and the banks seem a bit less wobbly, but today the spectre of unemployment looms, and tomorrow it will be something else.
In this more discerning climate the winners will be those who truly understand what is important to consumers, and offer great quality at a price which consumers think is worth paying.












Friday, 12 September 2008

Food Buying Habits - How, When, and Why Did It All Change?


Food shopping habits have changed. Consumers are changing where they shop, how they shop, and what they buy.


Morrisons, home of low prices, and Waitrose at the premium end of the scale, both published half year results a couple of days ago. Morrisons grew like for like sales by 7.6%, (like for like meaning sales in stores open at least a year), and profits by 19%. Waitrose grew sales by 2.5%, a third of the rate of Morrisons, were forced to cut some prices to compete and hold market share, and saw profits fall by 8%. ALDI, viewed as having the cheapest prices of the lot, is now said to be growing sales at about 30% versus last year. A confident statement from ASDA a few weeks ago indicated that they are doing just fine because they offer really low prices. And Sainsbury and the once the once invulnerable Tesco are losing out.


Consumers are changing what they buy. We know that organic sales are struggling, reportedly down 20% in August versus last year, that meat consumption is down 5% according to the latest figures published on the British Pig Executive website, and DairyCo says that milk consumption is down. Consumers are also buying more products in retailer's Value ranges. Morrisons showed a chart at their results presentation illustrating that across the whole of the grocery trade Value ranges were growing at about 8% in the spring, but have now rocketed to a growth of nearly 30%. By contrast Premium ranges growth has fallen from a high of 15% in March 08 to around 3% in August.


Other startling changes are happening. Sainsbury tell us that between July and August sales of tupperware containers have grown by 36%, and sandwich bags by 35%, as more people take sandwiches to work instead of buying ready made.


All in all, it seems that beleaguered Brits are leaving no stone unturned in an effort to spend less. The interesting thing though, is that although the credit crunch started almost a year ago with the Northern Rock wobble, the big changes in what and where people buy only started in the spring. Going back to Waitrose as an example, they were sailing along quite nicely until early summer.


Why the drop since then? Because that's when consumer confidence started to plummet,worn away by headlines about food price inflation, spikes in oil prices, mortgage worries, and warnings of rising energy bills Another chart from Morrisons shows that in March, consumers confidence levels were down by 18%, in August they were down by 40%. Or to put it another way, nearly half the country thinks things are going to get worse, much worse. If they are that worried, it's no wonder people are changing behaviour, battening down the hatches, and bracing themselves for what might be around the next corner.


What is clear though, is that doom mongers who say they always knew that all people want is cheap food are wrong. Despite the belt tightening, Premium sales are still growing albeit at a slower rate than previously. It does not look either as if shoppers are ditching ethical principles altogether. Waitrose says that consumers are still supporting welfare friendly food but choosing free range rather than organic to save some money. ASDA says its sales of organic produce have grown by 25%, and Morrisons reported that their sales of both Fair Trade and organic sales are growing.


As ever, it does seem as if those who offer good quality combined with good value (which is not the same thing as price) will ride out the storm, ready for an upturn in confidence.

Monday, 9 June 2008

Consumers,Clones and Concerns

The Food Standards Agency research findings that consumers do not support animal cloning for food have been widely reported, (apart from in the farming press, bizarrely), and both the findings themselves and consumer reactions to the reports merit pause for thought. The research is thorough, and the reports on it were confined to the facts, with no hysterical headlines. Media commentators reactions were also well balanced, with a couple of commentators coming out in support and one asking for a reasoned debate on the subject. The facts are though that consumers are unlikely to buy food from cloned animals.
In the research itself, people were worried about the animal welfare implications of cloning for both the mother who, because of the high failure rate risked becoming a breeding machine, and for offspring who in most instances are born with disease and deformity. People vividly remember BSE and CJD, and so were concerned about whether the food would be safe to eat; and they doubt whether those involved can be trusted, be they biotech companies, breeders, farmers, or retailers. All the worries were compounded by an inability to see any benefits from cloning apart from more profit to those in the cloning chain.
I don't think that this research can be dismissed as the views of a tiny number of people who may have particularly strong views about animal welfare or food safety or the ethics of cloning.Those taking part were screened to ensure they had no extreme ideas about any aspect of food, and findings are in fact very similar to those from America where they have carried out extensive research on the topic.
Reaction to media commentators columns also showed resistance from the public, but with a sizable minority being open minded. Melanie Reid in the Times came out strongly in favour of cloned food. 29 people were moved to respond to her views, of whom 8 said it sounded ok to them. The rest were strongly against, with some saying her piece was an illogical and factually incorrect piece of journalism. The Observer's Tim Haywood sat on the liberal fence saying that whilst he did not like the idea himself, there should be a reasoned debate about it, a point of view endorsed by 6 out of nine people commenting on his article. Hannah Strange also of the Times concluded that the animal welfare issues associated with cloning would mean that UK consumers would not support it.She drew one response saying that cloning needed the same animal welfare safeguards as ant other animal related activity, and one feeling that there was no cause for concern.Many of those reponding to articles, whether for or against,called for clear labelling so that consumers knew what they were buying and could avoid if they wished. The Mail, mouthpiece of middle England, reported the research and of the people who commented half were open minded, particularly if cloning would help feed the world.
At first sight therefore, public response seems more favourable than the FSA research might indicate. However there are two major findings which lead to the conclusion that UK consumers just will not buy cloned food.First, the research shows clearly that the more consumers know about cloning the more alarmed they get. As yet the cloning debate is still in its infancy in the UK, but anxiety will grow with more publicity. Second, there is a striking attitude difference between men and women. 60% of women reject outright the idea of buying cloned food, compared with one third of men. Conversely, about a third of men are prepared to buy cloned food, but only 14% of women.The key point here is that its still women who do most of the food shopping.
So, there are major drawbacks in consumers minds already about cloned meat, and as the debate unfolds there will be alot who will not accept it.
But this consumer unease won't come as a surprise to farmers, many of whom instinctively understand the public's feelings.

Monday, 7 April 2008

Ethical Purchasing and the Credit Crunch... Continued

Concern about whether the credit crunch will bring ethical purchasing to a halt seems to be exercising many minds. The latest to publish a survey is The Times newspaper.

In answer to the question "In the next year are you likely to .....", the 1000 people surveyed replied as follows:
Buy more organic food - 34%
Buy more Fair Trade products - 59%
Buy healthier food - 64%
Buy food that can guarantee a better deal for farmers - 66%
Buy more locally produced goods - 71%
Buy food with less packaging - 80%

The same survey also asked the question "Given the growing economic uncertainty, which of the following best describes how you would be likely to respond if you had to cut back on your consumer spending?" Answers to this question have been tracked over time, and are as follows:

Still try to buy the most ethical and environmentally friendly products I could
Nov o7 - 65%
Dec 07 - 69%
Jan 08 - 63%
Feb 08 - 69%
Be more likely to buy products and services that represented the best value for money regardless
Nov 07 - 35%
Dec 07 - 31%
Jan 08 - 37%
Feb 08 - 31%
Mar 08 - 35%
Mar 08 - 35%

The way consumers anwer questions about their intentions should always be treated with a high level of scepticism. What consumers say they will do and what they actually do are two very different things. This is particularly true when it comes to questioning consumers about their ethics. The best way of interpreting the data is probably like this. In the first table, the answers show what issues are highest on consumers minds, and what messages are getting through to them. So, they are irritated about excess packaging, which we know from many other surveys, and they are thinking favourably about locally produced foods, and fairness to farmers at home and abroad. They are less sure about organic foods though. I'd say the second table has little value given that many consumers won't want an interviewer to think badly of them, and so are unlikely to agree that ethics will go out of the window in favour of a better price.

Friday, 4 April 2008

Ethical Purchasing - Inside the Consumer's Head

The Institute of Grocery Distribution has previously provided data about the 5 ethical issues that most concern people, these being Animal Welfare, Local/British, Environmentally Friendly, Fair Trade, and Organics. See blog of 7/3/08 "Whither Ethical Purchasing" for detailed data.

Now, for anyone interested in what goes on inside consumers minds as they make an ethical purchase, IGD has published findings on how and why consumers decide what to buy.

According to IGD, consumers work to 7 guiding principles:

1. Personal beliefs about what food is right and what isn't.

2. Whether food has been produced in a way that is fair to all involved, be it people or animals, both at home and abroad.

3. Worries about sustainability and whether due thought has been given to the environmental impact of food production.

4. A desire to leave the world in a fit state for future generations.

5. Concern about health and well being, particularly if young children are involved.

6. Food safety as it relates to where the food has come from and how it was produced.

7. What makes the consumer feel good at the time of purchase.

It has to be said that some of these findings look a bit vague, and although the IGD doesn't mention this, not all consumers will act on all these principles all of the time. However, they do support the general view that consumers are becoming more aware of ethical issues. They also give clues about why consumers make a particular decision, whether it's to support the environment, or to be sure that no person or animal was badly treated, or whether more selfish motives such as health or feeling good come into play. The findings can also help those thinking about how to advertise their produce develop an appealing message for their customers.

Monday, 10 March 2008

Whither Ethical Purchasing - Update

Last week's post about ethical purchasing ended with my view that strong brands with a clear message are needed to help consumers navigate their way through an increasingly complicated set of ethical purchase decisions. Free range, Fairtrade and British were cited as examples of good brands. Organic was not because only 32% of consumers said they would be interested in organic products, compared with 59% for free range, 48% for Fairtrade, and 49% for British.


I may have been wrong to omit organics. It is after all a nearly £2billion market. And then along comes an article in the Sunday Telegraph. They reported a fund raising event in London this Thursday, sponsored by the Soil Association, to help children visit an organic farm. Organisers include minor glitterati such as model Sophie Dahl, actor Richard E Grant, Jemima Khan. Annie Lennox will be performing. Four hundred guests will attend.Tickets cost £1000 each. (No, not a typo!).


So the organic brand does have power for some. There can't be many branches of agriculture that would persuade people to pay £1000 for dinner. It would be nice if there were.

Friday, 7 March 2008

Whither Ethical Purchasing?

One of the questions of the day is whether rising food prices and a financially squeezed consumer will result in ethical purchase considerations taking second place to price. Not so far said the Institute of Grocery Distribution yesterday. Certainly the recent flight to free range/organic chicken seems to support their view, and it will be interesting to examine further data on ethical purchasing as it emerges.

It does seem as if food ethics are becoming top of mind for consumers.
The IGD has just done some research, and published figures on the interest levels which consumers have in various ethical product types.
%
Animal welfare (net) 69
Free range 59
Not tested on animals 35
High standards of animal welfare 34
Local/British (net) 55
British 49
Local regional 40
Environmentally friendly (net) 53
Minimum packaging 36
Recycled/biodegradable packaging 36
Sustainably managed sources 21
Committed to reducing carbon footprint 20
Not transported by air 11
Fair traded products 48
Organic products 32

The figures confirm the range of ethical worries facing the consumer. As the IGD points out, consumers also worry about the health implications of a purchase, and remain unprepared to accept low quality. Finally, these are interest levels, not what is actually purchased, which gets back to the need to translate interest into hard purchase.

But the most striking thing of all about these figures is how issues which are strongly branded, ie which stand for a clear simple message, receive the highest levels of purchase interest. Just look at free range, Fairtrade, and British. This need for a strong brand which captures the essence of an ethical issue is becoming vital. Consumers are definitely more interested in ethical products but along with the interest comes a whole new set of worries. Consumers are asking themselves whether it is ok to buy, say, string beans from Africa because they are Fairtrade, despite the food miles that might have been clocked up, and even though it means less veg bought from a local farmer. The dilemma is made worse as sophisticated marketing types fight to put ethical claims on to their products, and consumers try and decide which claim best fits their own view of what is right.

So. Should local foods be strongly branded, with a clear standards for what "local" means? Could the British brand be made stronger with standards that are more than just a baseline? What does environmentally friendly actually mean?

Food for thought perhaps.

Friday, 29 February 2008

Consumers, Chickens and Changing the World

Good heavens! Sales of free range chickens increased by 35% last month whereas standard sales dropped by 7%.(TNS data reported in yesterday's Independent). Free range sales could have been higher except the shelves were empty because supermarkets could not keep up with demand. The catalyst was programmes by celebrity chefs Jamie Oliver and Hugh Fearnley Whittingstall drawing attention to the conditions in which standard chickens are kept.

Some are linking this news with the growth in Fair Trade, which doubled last year to £500m, and M&S's decision to charge for plastic bags, and concluding that consumers can change the world. The conclusion is indeed right, but commentators are missing one big point. The growth of Fair Trade has resulted from supermarkets stocking more products, and, as in the case of bananas, selling only Fair Trade, so consumers don't have the option of buying any other type. Similarly the decision to charge for plastic bags is led by the supermarket.

What is different about the chickens is that supermarkets had nothing to do with the change in what consumers bought. Indeed, they were taken completely by surprise as the empty shelves show. The change in buying was wholly due to consumers seeing something they did not like and acting.

The power of the consumer should never be underestimated. The supermarkets are not totally in charge. What is needed to change consumers minds and buying habits is clear communication, from a trusted source.

Farmers might do well to ask themselves if the media rolled up at their farms would they be proud to let the cameras in. And the farming industry should be asking itself whether it policies and practices always merit the same level of trust that the likes of Jamie and Hugh.

Sunday, 17 February 2008

Bottled Water Backlash

All of a sudden, rumblings against bottled water are turning into a global outcry. Environmentalists condemn the product for the high levels of CO2 emitted while producing it, and the food miles clocked up in its distribution. Other critics just think its madness to spend money on something available from the tap at a fraction of the price. The backlash seems to have started in earnest in the US where at least one state has banned spending of public funds on the product, Mayor Bloomberg of New York has condemned it, and Chicago has enforced a 5 cents bottled water tax. Anti bottled water articles and comment are now flooding the British media, fuelled by environment minister Phil Woolas calling drinking bottled water "daft", and "verging on the immoral". The shadow environment minister has endorsed Mr.Woolas's comments. BBC's Panorama is doing a programme tomorrow (Monday), examining the bottled water industry, and its unlikely to be favourable.



The backlash has reached New Zealand, and the issues surrounding bottled water have been covered in the United Arab Emirates and India. The Catholic Patriarch of Venice has suggested giving up bottled water for Lent, and donating the cash saved to a water pipeline project in Thailand. He is supported by his mayor who calls bottled water an unnecessary luxury.



What could have brought on this groundswell of negative opinions? Certainly environmental campaigners around the world have played a big part. Recent coverage in the UK will have been heightened by the Woolas article, and its worth noting that Thames Water, in conjunction with a government funded body called the Council for Water are encouraging caterers to supply tap water for diners without being asked for it, so presumably some of the publicity comes from them. There may well be a touch of anti big business playing a part as the bulk of the bottled water market profits go to Nestle, Coca Cola and Pepsi. Whatever the reasons, the companies selling bottled water in the UK are sufficiently concerned to have set up a body to counteract the bad publicity (the Bottled Water Information Office). They are reported to be preparing a campaign later in the year to promote the health benefits of bottled waters, and the steps being taken to reduce the environmental impact of the product.


Why should farming be so concerned with bottled water? Well, there seem to be parallels with the issue of livestock farming and its impact on the environment. At the moment the calls for a reduction in eating meat or dairy to protect the environment are rumblings. What is desperately needed is for the farming industry to communicate its environmental strategy before the rumblings become louder.

Friday, 1 February 2008

Cloned Food

I'm surprised there's been so little fuss in the UK about cloned food.

On 11th January the European Food Standards Authority (Efsa) announced its conclusion that products from cloned pigs and cattle are unlikely to be a threat to food safety or the environment but that products should be labelled as cloned. It admitted that cloning has significant animal health and welfare issues. It was silent on the ethics of cloning. Comments from the public are requested by 25th February.

The next day the European Group on Ethics in Science and New Technology, reporting to the European Commission said "considering the level of suffering and health problems (to animals) EGE has doubts as to whether cloning animals is ethically justified". It went on to say that it does not see convincing arguments to justify the production of food from clones and their offspring.

But where is the outcry to get cloning stopped? Yes, the Soil Association, RSPCA, Compassion in World Farming and Friends of the Earth have spoken out against the practice, the media have reported the factual news, and supermarkets has said that they will not sell cloned products.To date though, there have been no questions raised in Parliament, no newspaper editorials providing a view, no surveys done among the public to see what they feel about the issue. The NFU say they will be guided by the science, which sidesteps the ethics, and see no need for labelling. Major food processors do not appear to have commented.


Contrast this with what has happened in America where the FDA announcement on 14th January that food from cloned cattle, pigs and goats is safe to sell into the food chain has caused outrage. The ruling was made in the teeth of four years of furious opposition from consumers, around 60% of whom have consistently said in research polls that they oppose cloned food on ethical and safety grounds, and from Congress for reasons of ethics and lack of robust data. Fury has been heightened by the decision not to require specific labelling, leaving the public with no idea whether they are eating cloned food or not. Big food processors and retailers have declared that they will not sell cloned foods. Even the NFU has said that if cloned food is to be sold then it needs to be labelled saying "consumers have a right to know if their food comes from cloned animals". The continued outcry has had an effect. The US Department of Agriculture has asked for the moratorium on cloned food sales to be continued to "allow sufficient time to prepare so that a smooth and seamless transition can occur". Which has been translated as buying time so that consumers can be educated.


It all raises the question of how on earth cloning animals for food has got as far as it has in the US. Clearly there are issues of ethics, unease, and compassion, meaning that consumers don't want to buy the products, food companies don't want to process them, and retailers don't want to sell them.

Getting back to the UK, why is it all so quiet here? Perhaps an announcement from Europe does not have the same impact as one from here at home. Perhaps people think it will never happen. Perhaps a short news report in the brain dead days just after Xmas isn't sufficient to raise awareness.Hopefully its just that it's early days in the process, and when the penny drops the UK public will spring into action with widespread and spirited campaigning. It worked on GM foods.

Monday, 28 January 2008

Trendspotting 2008

As economic gloom rises, access to cheap credit evaporates, nervousness sets in about spending the money we've got, and rising food costs have registered even on the affluent, it is timely to ask whether a hunt for lowest possible food prices is set to obliterate any other considerations in consumers' minds. Applying some tried and tested lessons about consumer behaviour when the going gets tougher may help answer the question. So, somewhat bravely, here are predictions about food market trends in 2008.

Value not price

At times of economic pressure people search harder for value, which is different from just looking at sticker price. Value is a combination of price, quality, and feeling good about a purchase. Its perhaps best summed up as answering yes to the question "is this worth it?". Top quality, fairly priced products will continue to sell well. Anything seen as pricey for what it is will not, and supermarket top tier product staples such as meat, fruit, veg and dairy may struggle unless they are clearly better than alternatives.

Environmental concern

This is here to stay largely due to the high level of publicity it receives. Products and services seen to be beneficial to the environment will continue to see sales growth.

Provenance/Ethical purchasing/Health

These trends have been combined as they are closely related in consumers' minds. Provenance may be described as "can I trust the source of this food and how it got here". The link with health comes because consumers are worried for health reasons about what goes into their food and how it is processed. They worry for ethical reasons about where it has come from and how far, how the animals have been treated, and have the producers been fairly rewarded. All these concerns have combined to power sales of local food, organics, fair trade, and special animal welfare schemes, even though the sticker price is usually higher than for other options. The forecast for all these sectors is continued growth, albeit at a lower rate than historically. Those who are truly committed will not change buying habits, but occasional purchasers if pushed for cash may buy less often.

Channels of purchase

The places people buy from and the way they buy are also likely to change. People drawing in their purchasing horns may choose to eat out less, or trade down in the amount they are spending on a night out. So sales through catering channels will slow or even decline. One channel which could grow is internet grocery shopping which saves petrol costs, and food miles, and is more convenient.

So in the end....

Though conditions may be tough, and overall growth may slow, there is unlikely to be a major reverse in the encouraging trend towards consumers caring more about their food, and being prepared to pay that bit extra for top quality, fairly priced products that help them live lives that they can feel good about.







Tuesday, 13 November 2007

What Makes a Food Premium?


There is much talk of consumers buying more premium food.

Producing a premium, added value product can deliver bigger profit simply because the higher amount that consumers pay means more money to be distributed through the food chain. Research published by the Institute of Grocery Distribution (http://www.igd.com/) in spring this year provides useful data for farmers wrestling with the problem of how to add value to their produce. So what makes a food premium? Here are some figures.

% consumers saying what makes a premium product:

High quality ingredients used - 41%

Well known brand - 33%

Free range - 23%

Organic - 21%

Locally produced - 19%

Fair trade - 17%

Added health benefits - 17%

Packaging looks good - 13%

Environmentally friendly - 12%

Retailers best own brand - 10%

Quality assurance standards - 10%

High animal welfare - 8%

The figures highlight that many consumers feel that ethical standards also mean premium, whether high animal welfare, environmentally friendly, free range or fair trade. It is also clear that locally produced and organic also equate to premium, and it is likely that ethical considerations influence this also. Other research indicates that consumers buy local because it is better for the environment (less food miles), and they can check for themselves that the farmer is committed to high welfare standards. Organic research also indicates that people buy for ethical reasons.

However two factors stand out as reasons that consumers see a food as premium. First, the product has to be made from high quality ingredients. This means that however ethical the product is it will not be seen as premium unless it is top quality. And second, the product has to be strongly branded, and stand for something consumers can trust. Which means a consistently good eating experience, wrapped up in good looking packaging, with a crisp name and a persuasive reason for the consumer to buy again and again.