Showing posts with label Morrisons. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Morrisons. Show all posts

Tuesday, 22 September 2015

Mixed Fortunes in Online – Waitrose down, Ocado static and Morrisons struggle with profit

The online conundrum continues. No one seems to have worked out how to find the holy grail of growth in both sales and profits.

Waitrose, purveyors of food to the well heeled, surprised market watchers last week with the news that their total like for like sales dropped by 1.3% in the last 6 months, the first decline in over 6 years. Even more surprising was the news that online sales plummeted by 13% due it seems to pulling out of promotional activity.

Ocado, equally upmarket, and an online only business, announced by contrast that its sales had grown by 15.3% in the last three months, roughly the same rate as in previous quarters.  Amount spent per order continues to drop.

Morrisons, who were late into online and partnered with Ocado to get going, did not declare sales, but CEO David Potts hinted at profitability problems, saying about the tie up with Ocado “ Its very important that it does become profitable growth. At the moment it is best expressed as an internet investment.”

Running an online operation appears to be a drain on both retailer and manufacturer profitability.

The Institute of Grocery Distribution just a week before the above results were announced published an article entitled “Five killerquestions to ask when moving online”. The third question, “can you invest for growth?”, resulted from  IGD’s finding that many manufacturers, even larger ones, are still mastering the basics of online retailing, and need to spend more money on developing their online offer, particularly in understanding shopper behaviour.

Operating in online grocery shopping does seem to come at a heavy financial cost.




Monday, 13 October 2014

Supermarket Price Promises – Mostly Smoke and Mirrors

Shoppers’ continued search for value, and the onslaught of discount grocers has led to the Big 4 supermarkets are tying themselves in knots trying to assure their shoppers that they offer the same prices as their competitors.

All claim that the shopper can be confident that their purchases will be no more expensive than if they had bought elsewhere, but close examination suggests that the initiatives being run by the supermarkets are mostly smoke and mirrors designed to give the illusion of value but in reality offering little of substance.

No store hands back hard cash if they are found to be more expensive. Instead Tesco, Sainsbury and Asda hand over vouchers and Morrisons has a complicated scheme where a card has to be obtained, points are added to the card when purchase at another store would have been cheaper, and the points are eventually traded in for a voucher. Voucher schemes benefit the supermarket because many will have been lost or forgotten about before they expire.
There are other wheezes designed to limit supermarket exposure. Sainsbury only compares with Asda, dropping the comparison with Tesco in a recent change designed to save money. Asda makes the shopper do the comparison work. It guarantees to be 10% cheaper than the other three major supermarkets but the shopper has to go online, enter till receipt details to find if their shop could have been cheaper elsewhere, and then claim their voucher.
There are a myriad of exclusions and exceptions to the various price promises. To be fair, Tesco’s Price Match covers all shops big and small, and fresh and own label products as well as branded. Morrisons compares with Lidl and Aldi as well as the majors across branded and own label. But Sainsbury does not offer its Brand Match in convenience stores, neither does Morrisons, and Sainsbury only compares branded prices.  All the supermarkets stipulate a minimum spend. No store gives out a voucher worth more than £10. Many everyday items are excluded such as baby formula.
There will be shoppers who have the time to go into the detail and work out how to make these pricing initiatives work in their favour. Many though will quickly conclude that the only thing that counts when shopping is the size of the bill week in and week out.
Which takes us back to Lidl and Aldi.
Despite the flurry of reduced prices and price promises among the “Big 4” both discount stores continue to flourish. Add to this Aldi’s recent commitment to keep the price differential between themselves and conventional supermarkets at a minimum of 15%, and it is difficult to see how the majors can hold their position without concrete and continued price reductions across their whole range of goods. So far, they are only playing at delivering competitive prices.




Friday, 12 September 2014

Discount Grocers - Growing Now But Will it Last?

With Morrisons announcing a halving of their profits and a 7.4% like for like sales decline, and Waitrose facing profits down 9.4%, despite delivering a bit of growth (up 1.3% in like for like sales) it seems timely to examine reasons for the seemingly unstoppable rise of discount grocers.

New store openings are a big contributor to their growth. Aldi opened 42 stores in 2013, and will add a further 54 new stores this year.

Another key factor is their ever-widening appeal. Discount grocers can no longer be seen as a specialised shopping experience favoured by the financially hard pressed. Recent IGD (Institute of Grocery Distribution) data suggests that 26% of shoppers visiting discount grocers fall into the affluent AB category compared with 27% for traditional supermarkets. Conversely 26% of DE shoppers visit discounters compared with 25% visiting supermarkets. In August 2014, 54% of all shoppers in the UK claimed to have  visited a discount store in the past month, up from 45% in August 2013, and the average spend per visit has increased by 15%.

Despite the growth, discounters rely heavily on top up shopping. They have not captured a big share of the main grocery shop. Just 15% say that a discounter is their main store. If discounters want to continue growing they need to get more shoppers spending more per visit.

In theory they seem ready and willing to do so. A third of them agree strongly that they would use discounters more if they could get their main shop there.

But before they make an Aldi or Lidl a main shop, customers want to see more products. They want more fruit and veg , and they want to buy food for their evening meal. They want to be able to buy products for special occasions, and they want a range of staples.

So basically what they are asking for is supermarket variety at discounter prices. That is a challenge for discounters as they try to fit customer demand for more products into a business model which until now has relied on a small, high volume range manufactured at rock bottom prices. Discounters also need to address the march of technology. They are a long way behind mainstream grocers in producing smartphone and tablet friendly apps designed to make shopping quicker and easier.

It is probably safe to predict further years of fast growth. Aldi is committed to a near doubling of stores by 2021, up from the current 531 to 1000. The number of shoppers visiting a discounter will rise from the current 54%, and the emergence of Netto as a Sainsbury partner will mean even more opportunities for shoppers to visit a discount store.


Thereafter the going might get tougher as mainstream grocers start fighting back with competitive pricing strategies, intelligent use of variety and choice, and customer friendly technology.

Monday, 24 March 2014

The Nightmare Scenario - Could Morrisons be Broken up and Sold Off, Leaving Just Three Big Supermarkets?


It was just a small piece in the Times this morning but it should send a chill through every one who supplies supermarkets.

The piece suggested that troubled Morrisons was being closely examined by private equity firms with a view to being bought and broken up, thereby generating mountains of quick, easy cash.

The writer went on to say that Sainsbury would love to get their hands on the 100 convenience stores that Morrisons have developed, because it would help them better compete with Tesco, and that ASDA might like to buy the superstores.

It is just speculation of course. There would probably be competition issues, given that the combined share of Morrisons and ASDA would be around 27%.

But the thought of there being only three big players in the UK grocery marketplace is alarming to put it mildly. Pressure on suppliers is tough enough with 4 major companies vying for sales and profit.

And Morrisons, the latest decision to stock New Zealand lamb during the winter apart, is a strong supporter of British farming, especially livestock.  Speaking as a farmer supplier to Morrisons I can say that they are fair and efficient too.

Morrisons will survive if they concentrate on what made them successful in the first place - selling top quality fresh food at prices cheaper than the competition. They are uniquely placed to do this because they own their own abattoirs, fruit and veg packing houses, and  bakery. Their commitment to reducing prices by £1billion is a first step towards a recovery, but given that their competitors will follow them down in price, it is to be hoped that the cost benefit of vertical integration means that Morrisons ultimately will win a pricing war.

Less easy to call is whether their new emphasis on convenience and online shopping risks taking their eye off the main ball which is getting core customers back into the stores.

Anyway, such decisions are down to Dalton Phillips, the man in charge of Morrisons. Every supplier to supermarkets should be keeping everything crossed that he sorts out a recovery strategy soon, and sees off any attempt from private equity firms to buy the business.



Monday, 13 January 2014

Spotlight on Morrisons – Why is it Struggling and What Can be Done to Stop the Rot


Supermarkets, apart from ASDA, have now reported their Christmas trading results. “Patchy” might be a good description with Aldi, Lidl and Waitrose booming, Marks and Spencer doing well, but Tesco and Morrisons down on the previous year. Even Sainsbury only managed 0.2% growth.

It was Morrisons who shocked most with a 5.6% drop in sales versus the previous year, and this at a time when the economy is generally agreed to be picking up.

Their performance highlights both long and short term issues. Their long term problems are well documented. Until last week they had no online presence at a time when more consumers are turning to the internet for grocery shopping: and they have few convenience stores which puts them at a disadvantage as people move away from mid week top up shopping in bigger stores, preferring to avoid temptation and buy just the essentials at their local convenience store.
   
Yet, neither Aldi nor Lidl offer online, and have few convenience shops, and Tesco offers both but is struggling.

Morrisons problems must therefore be more deep rooted than lagging behind in two growth areas.

Perhaps their biggest issue is that shoppers cannot see a compelling reason to shop at Morrisons. They are uncompetitive on price versus the discounters, and lack the quality reputation of Waitrose or Sainsbury. This lack of clarity about what the brand stands for is obvious when viewing the Morrisons Christmas advert, where the four points made about Morrison’s offer (service, wide variety, having their own chefs and “putting on a show for little dough”) were eclipsed by the undoubted star quality of Ant and Dec. Four messages were three too many,  and money would have been better spent on articulating one reason to shop at Morrisons rather than waste hundreds of thousands on personalities who drown out the message.

So Morrisons must get back to its roots and the core values that made it into a success. The company will have reams of consumer research to guide them, but price and value for money are likely to figure strongly.

Morrisons are too small to be able to match the discounters on the price of packaged goods. Both Aldi and Lidl are huge internationally and can use their buying clout to keep prices rock bottom. Rather, Morrisons should be focussing on the one thing that all of their competitors will find difficult to match, which is that Morrisons, by owning their own abattoirs, bakeries and fresh fruit and veg packing houses can offer fresh food at unbeatable prices.

They need also to be true to their values. It did not receive much publicity but at the back end of 2012 they started to stock an imported red meat brand called Helmsley. This was followed in November 2013 by imported chicken. Such stepping away from their stated policy of selling only UK produced meat does little to boost consumer confidence, and is the sign of a muddled thinking business.

It is to be hoped that Morrisons swiftly get back on track. The supermarket sector needs competition. The more successful supermarkets there are to choose from

the better for all in the food chain.



Tuesday, 28 May 2013

More Evidence That Food Retailers Need an Online Operation

Hardly a day passes without reference to the rise of on line shopping and how it will affect the retail landscape.

Last week we heard that Morrisons supermarket are paying £170m to Ocado for their depot in Warwickshire, a further £30m to license their technology, plus 1% of any Morrisons online sales and 25% of any cash profits. They also threw in £46m to expand the Warwick depot, and a contribution to Research and Development costs.

Whether one thinks that Morrisons are out of their minds to get involved with Ocado, whose business model is far from a successful example of how to compete in online grocery retailing, or whether your view might be that this is an excellent  move for all concerned, what is unarguable is that Morrisons felt so pressurised about the adverse impact of not being on line that they were prepared to pay handsomely for a way in.

Today the Centre for Retailing Research heaped on the pressure by publishing a report claiming that the percentage of sales made on line will rise from 12.7% in 2012 to 21.5% sometime between 2018 and the end of the decade.

They make the chilling prediction that the rise will result in a loss of some 316,000 jobs,  that total store numbers will fall by 22% from 281,930 today to 220,000, and that a further 164 major or medium sized companies will go into administration.

As ever it is the consumer who is driving the change.  Shoppers’ way of buying has changed out of all recognition in just a few years. Nowadays, having read up all the reviews about a potential product on line, they can choose to visit a store and buy then and there, (having just checked on their smartphone that the prices on offer cannot be beaten by a competing store).Or they can use the store to see what a product looks and feels like and then go home and buy online. Even then they have a choice – to have the product delivered to their home or, rather than wait in, to collect at a convenient specified outlet.

As to food, the Centre concedes that purchasing food online has not exploded on the same way as other sectors, but predicts that online food sales will rise from 3.7% today to 9.5% by 2018, largely driven by the supermarkets investing heavily in this way of shopping.

There are substantial obstacles to overcome. There are reasons why shoppers have not enthusiastically embraced the internet to buy food.

The IGD tells us that consumers are still worried about the quality of fresh food bought on line, and that this remains one of the biggest barriers. 2 in 5 shoppers want longer shelf lives on products but this alone will not solve it. The taste and look of fresh products bought online continues to be highly variable.

Reliable delivery times are also critical, as is confidence that what is ordered will be what arrives on the doorstep. 90% of online shoppers report that a reliable delivery service is a major factor in deciding which supermarket to buy from.

And of course, prices and promotions must at least match what is happening in the store itself.

Buying groceries on line is not yet the ingrained behaviour that is evident in other categories. Most people shop online every now and then. Others have a more regular approach. But very few buy weekly, and the number doing so is dropping.

There are many problems to solve, not least that online as a way of retailing groceries is much less profitable than via the store.

It would seem though that all involved in selling food need to factor in the online issues when they review their business strategies.






Wednesday, 6 March 2013

Online Grocery Shopping - Supermarket Giant Morrisons View on the Challenges


Dalton Phillips, CEO of Morrisons, speaking on Radio 4 about his company’s future prospects, has given a clear analysis of the challenges food retailers face when considering going into online grocery shopping.

The basic problem, he says, is that when it comes to online, the mechanics involved in the cost of shopping transfer from the shopper to the supermarket.

The shopper going to a supermarket pays the time cost of going round the aisles loading products into the trolley, the time cost of wheeling the goods out to out to the car and loading up, and  the time and transport costs of getting the product home. Should the shopper arrive home with the wrong products they have to lump it – no getting on the phone or computer to complain that what they wanted has not arrived, no “goodwill” compensatory money changes hands to soothe disgruntlement.

Once the shopper orders on line all of those costs pass to the supermarket. The supermarket has to have the staff to process the order, pick the goods, load them onto the van, deliver to the customer’s house, deal with complaints. They have to buy or lease the vans, and bear the petrol and insurance costs of going around the country to deliver. We know from various industry studies that the cost of processing an on line order is about £15. Yet the shopper pays about £5, less if placing a big order.

Dalton Phillips point is that someone has to pick up the tab for all this additional cost, and none of the options is palatable. The competitive jungle that is the grocery sector means that costs cannot be passed back to shoppers in the form of higher prices. Equally, a hit to profit margins is unlikely to please investors.
What Dalton Phillips perhaps has not accepted is that embracing online grocery shopping means a structural and permanent change to the way profits are made by the grocery trade. At the moment online is a small part of supermarket sales, and so the profit drain is largely disguised, but this will change if the sector grows as predicted.

 Morrisons may not have much choice in whether or not they offer an online service. On line is something that today’s food shoppers want and to ignore the trend is to risk being sidelined, perhaps not today or tomorrow but certainly in the longer term. British retailing history is littered with examples of big businesses which ignored trends, got stuck in the past and collapsed. Comet, Jessops and Blockbuster spring to mind.

The challenge for Morrisons and any other business developing an online facility is to work out how to adjust business performance to take account of the reduced profit margin which comes from an online presence.

Friday, 13 January 2012

Tesco Pays the Price for Ignoring its Customers



It’s been a dramatic week for  supermarket watchers.

First, Morrisons who had been the clear leaders in the grocery war of late announced that their sales over Xmas period had grown by a tiny 0.7%. Dalton Phillips their Canadian chief executive said it was because cash strapped Brits were unwilling to splash out over the festive season.
Somewhat contrary to this picture of austerity consciousness, Waitrose announced sales growth of +3.8%. Now as anyone who has ventured through the doors of a Waitrose will know their food is not cheap, even following much publicised activities such as a price match with Tesco on 1000 lines.  Next came Marks and Spencer, also not a cheap place to shop, with sales growth of 3%. According to ex Morrisons chief executive Marc Bolland this was due to the introduction of 600 new products, and keen pricing on some lines. Indeed M&S customers seem to be gregarious types, powering sales of party packs of food to by 8% and fresh turkey by 25%.

Then we heard from Sainsbury with sales up 2.1%. According to their head man Justin King, their premium Taste the Difference range grew by 10%, but he did concede that at the other end of the scale their cheaper value range grew by 7%.

We have not heard from ASDA yet but they are reported by market researchers Nielsen to have had a good Christmas sales performance also.
And what can we say about Tesco whose Christmas trading performance was nothing short of dire, with sales down 2.3%. It is not just a short term issue either.  According to their chief executive Philip Clarke, Tesco’s “entire shopping experience” is not as good as it should be and he indicated that Tesco has failed for years to deliver on product availability, service and food quality.

And thereby hangs the clue as to what makes the difference between winners and losers. Yes, indeed British consumers are feeling the pinch, scrutinising all costs, budgeting, cutting down on waste. But, they are prepared to spend their money with grocers who offer the combination of price, quality, and specialness which makes them feel as if their money has been well spent.
The “upmarket” grocers between them have about 25% of the market and despite cash strapped times were rewarded because they offered that critical concept of value for money that consumers seek, especially when money is tight.

Those who keep close to their customers and listen to them generally do well. Tesco has not been listening, and has not done so for years, resulting in lost customers and falling market share.
Turning a deaf ear to customer needs leads to problems.  

Wednesday, 14 September 2011

Going for Growth - How Marks and Spencer, Waitrose, Morrisons and Aldi are Tackling the Challenge

Growth remains the holy grail for all supermarkets. Here we look at four different approaches -   M&S and Waitrose at the premium end of the market, Morrisons in the mainstream, and Aldi the discount chain.

The discount sector remains an endless source of fascination for supermarket watchers because the business models are so different from the mainstream, but their growth rates are tremendous. In the 12 weeks to September 4th, Aldi has grown by 26% and LIDL by 13%. This run of growth has been going on for months. Part of it is down to the demise of Netto, meaning that discount fans have had to transfer their allegiance, part of it is a response to rising food prices and shrinking disposable income. Interestingly though, the growth has come for the most part from loyal discount shoppers who previously would divide spend between discounters and say Tesco, but who now choose to spend an increasing proportion in the discount shop. The actual number of new discount shoppers is small.

So the Aldi challenge is to persuade those shoppers who already like much of what they see in Aldi to spend an increasing amount of their grocery budget there. And the key to achieving the objective is to bring the quality of its fresh food up to that of its packaged goods, but maintaining value. Already work is underway and Aldi stand a very good chance of continuing the growth levels already experienced.
Morrisons is one of the “big four” supermarkets, and the only one growing faster than the market average. It is managing to combine growth with increased profits.

Their success so far is down to the quality and value of their fresh food, and they now want to extend this expertise to online shopping. To this end they purchased a stake in FreshDirect,  the New York based company heralded as a leader in online. If Morrisons get this right they could be on to a winner as one of the main gripes about buying food on line is that fresh food is of variable quality, too near its sell by date and often the first choice is substituted for something less acceptable.

Waitrose today published its half year results, and whilst it is achieving sales growth of 9%, profits are down by 14%. Waitrose is chasing growth in a big way, by opening more stores, improving its online business, and promoting more heavily. Its challenge is to expand from its niche without losing the emphasis on quality and service that has made it successful, and the strategy is not without risk. As a privately owned company it has more time than most to get the model right, but at some stage it will need to restore profitability.
The M&S challenge is different. You cannot do your weekly shop there, so what CEO Marc Bolland and the team have to do is develop a food offer that cannot be bought in supermarkets. The answer according to Bolland is to make M&S even more special, putting delicatessens into bigger shops, upping the specialness of the bakery section, and featuring products little known in the UK but acknowledged as outstanding in other countries like Iberico ham and fresh burrata cheese (a mixture of mozzarella and cream apparently!).

These  moves are unlikely to transform performance. Introducing such products is merely a difference of degree – another step along the rarity spectrum. It is not the radical, totally new meeting of a consumer need that has characterised M&S success in food in the past. In bygone days M&S was noted for pioneering, whether it was exotic sandwiches where previously only cheese and pickle was available, or ready meals which allowed a harassed meal provider to put something on the table which not only tasted great but was whipped up in half an hour, or previously unheard of  fruit and veg.

Here we have four different companies all with different growth strategies. All will be convinced that their strategies will be successful. Time will tell who has got it right.


Sunday, 4 April 2010

Local Foods – From Niche to Mainstream in 5 Years

In early 2005, the local food movement was mostly confined to farmers markets, a few intrepid souls selling by mail order or over the internet, one or two up market shops sufficiently different to flourish despite the supermarkets, and funnily enough, ASDA who had just begun to experiment with local foods in its Kendal store.

Now local foods are a feature of every supermarket’s business. ASDA has gone from strength to strength, and now asks its shoppers to write in with suggestions for local foods they want stocked. Tesco says they sold £624 million worth of local foods in 2009, around 2.2% of its sales, and a 30% increase since 2007. Morrisons make a big thing of sourcing local products such as pies, unusual cheeses and the monthly guest ale. Smaller stores are benefitting too, and shopper interest in local foods has played a part in encouraging specialised shops to return to the high street.

Recent IGD research has found that 30% of people purchased locally produced food in the last month, up from just 15% in 2006. This compares with 17% buying organic, also up from 15% in 2006.

This rapid growth comes about because people have a very clear idea about why they buy local food.

The number 1 reason for buying local is freshness. 57% of shoppers perceive local food to be fresher because it has not travelled very far. 54% buy because of a wish to support local producers. About a third buy local because they wish to support local retailers. Other reasons for buying local are environment, naturalness, and the security of knowing where the food has come from and how it has been produced.

The growth will continue. This is a trend, not a fad.

Consumers clearly like the idea of buying local. It is an easy purchase, particularly if prices are similar to a non local version, which is nearly always the case in supermarkets, and will probably need to be in smaller shops unless they are offering something very special.

One challenge is to pin down exactly what local means to consumers in terms of geography. IGD research tells us that in Scotland and Wales, “local” is seen to be from that country. In England, according to some work done by the Food Standards Agency, the definition tends to be based either on mileage (which can be anywhere from 10 miles if a country dweller, to 100 if living in London), or on counties around where the person lives. My view would be that whatever the definition, it is important that consumers don’t feel cheated by a local claim.

It is also important to avoid thinking that being local is either a substitute for strong branding or a passport to a premium price. This is especially true if selling to supermarkets.

The final comment would be that a move from niche to mainstream almost always means a move from high to lower prices.

Thursday, 25 February 2010

Shopper Buying Behaviour - Insights from the NFU Conference

Edward Garner of Kantar Worldpanel ( previously called TNS) spoke yesterday about whether recent events like the move away from discounters, a decline in sales of value ranges, the resurgence of Waitrose and a swing to buying premium food over Christmas heralded the end of recessionary food buying behaviour. He did not offer a conclusion but en route to a fence sitting finale he did offer interesting nuggets about shoppers and the way they buy from the major supermarkets.

ASDA
The main message here is that ASDA is all about lowest price. When questioned, the overwhelming reason consumers give for shopping at ASDA is low prices., and it is ASDA who has gained most from the trend away from discounters. ASDA’s most recent price wheeze is to sell at a “round pound” price point, and in the last 12 weeks items priced at £1 have accounted for 14% of all sales. The round pound price point extends to £2, £3, £4 etc, and in total accounted for 22% of sales. Suppliers are being encouraged to tailor their products to sell at these particular prices.

The other side of the coin is that ASDA are not rated highly on quality. They undertrade on fresh and chilled foods, meaning their share of these is less than their total share, sales of their premium range are falling, and their organic sales are down 25% in the last twelve weeks, the worst performance of all supermarkets. (Note that ASDA would argue that they have upgraded quality and won lots of awards, but the Worldpanel figures suggest shoppers are not on the same page.)

Edward Garner did not say, but this obsession with price, coupled with a slight share decline over Christmas, may explain why Andy Bond who runs ASDA took the odd step of doing a public video in which he lambasted suppliers for not reducing prices when costs fell back , preferring instead to offer promotions which he termed “Weapons of Mass Distraction”. Bond declared that ASDA would “return with force” to its “Every day Low Price Strategy”, which he believes is best for customers, suppliers and shareholders. Other supermarkets might disagree.

Morrisons
Morrisons tends to be lumped with ASDA as a low price store, and certainly is seen by customers as offering good value, but it is changing its image and performing well. Morrisons overtrades by 3% in fresh and chilled foods, and by a huge 14% in fresh meat. As Garner says, something for farmers to be aware of. Also Morrisons is growing its number of wealthier customers, classed AB’s, who generally have more spending power.

Tesco
The news here is that their premium range is growing, and their discount range, introduced to fight Aldi and Lidl, only accounts for 1% of sales. Apparently the claim to be Britain’s biggest discounter backfired as we shoppers do not like to be told that we are buying cheap goods.

Waitrose
Waitrose has been doing well as shoppers get over the shock of inflationary price rises. Essentials, which Garner stressed is not a value range, but rather a communication exercise designed to make shoppers re- evaluate the store, has helped.

Marks and Spencer
Still a big problem, due to a lack of regular customers.

Fair Trade, Organics, Local Foods, and High Welfare
Sainsbury remains the biggest seller of Fair Trade products, and Waitrose sells 4.5 times more organic produce than its market share. However organic food has still not regained its position and Garner feels that the term organic will become a statement of production rather than a prime reason to buy.

Local Food sales are booming, and supermarkets are increasing the shelf space devoted to them.

High welfare products also continue to grow. 60% of all eggs sold in retail are now free range, despite costing about 30% more to buy, and free range chicken sales are also growing albeit at a slower rate.

Garner ended by saying that many industry watchers feel recessionary food buying habits may not have gone away because tax rises and spending cuts will breed uncertainty. On the other hand, he said, food only accounts for about 8% of overall consumer spend and so may not be the first port of call for consumer cutbacks.

If asked to come down on one side or the other, I’d say that there will be no return to unthinking spending any time soon, that people will pay for what they value whether it be premium ingredients or ethical beliefs, and not just follow lowest price, and that poor quality will not be tolerated.

Friday, 20 November 2009

What Will Marc Bolland Do To Revive M&S Food Business?


Marc Bolland’s move to Marks & Spencer has sparked excitement in the City and attracted acres of coverage in mainstream news. The interest reflects M&S’s position as jewel of the High Street, leading purveyor of the nation’s underwear, and reliable backstop when looking for clothing basics - and Bolland’s success at supermarket giant Morrisons.

Marks badly needs someone who can revive it's £4.2bn turnover food business. Performance has been nothing short of dismal with falling margins and severe loss of market share, and the decline cannot be put down to difficult economic times. The problems arose well before the credit crunch, and continue despite a slight loosening of consumer purse strings, and recovery in its rival Waitrose.

Mr. Bolland's experience at Morrisons equips him well for the challenge. So what might he do?



First he has to understand what the problem is. Current management seems to think it is all about price, and has responded with hundreds of offers and deals such as “Dine in for £10”. This might help in the short term as Marks' food is expensive, but it is not a long term fix. Neither is the plan to introduce branded products such as Coca Cola, for Marks has neither the expertise nor the buying power to be a general grocery shop. What Marc Bolland must do is solve the basic problem which is this - as of today there is no compelling reason either to visit M&S on a regular basis, or to spend much when you get there.

How different it was a few years ago. M&S's initial success came because it offered outstanding quality which was unavailable from anywhere else. Then in a brilliant piece of market understanding and pioneering innovation it developed its range of ready meals, offering culinary delights which an increasingly widely travelled public encountered when abroad but had no idea how to replicate at home. Ready meal sales went from strength to strength as time pressed but affluent consumers bought a no-preparation evening meal, not giving too much thought to nutritional content or having to double up because portion sizes were tiny. M&S sandwiches were a leading development too, offering fresh and delicious lunchtime fodder at a time when the only takeaway food was a sausage roll and packet of crisps.

But then the world caught up with Marks. Supermarkets matched them on quality by introducing premium ranges, consumers shunned ready meals preferring instead to do some actual cooking at half the price and twice the goodness, and lunchtime options became available everywhere from the likes of Gregg’s the bakers, or coffee outlets such as Costa and Starbucks.

So Mr. Bolland, what is needed here is a return to the historical ability of Marks and Spencer to see the future with crystal clarity, to anticipate consumer trends, and give us what we want before we even realise we want it.

Supplier Relationships
On the supplier relationship side, we know that Morrisons supported British farmers under Bolland’s leadership, committing to stocking only British beef and lamb. Also that they set up Morrisons Farm, a 700 acre holding on the Dumfries house estate in Scotland where the objective is to be a “leading centre of excellence in applied farming research”. It is to be hoped that he will continue Marks’ constructive approach to farming relationships, and commitment to stocking only British beef, salmon, chicken, pork and turkey. He might even go all British on lamb. Whether he will bring a tougher negotiating stance generally to suppliers remains to be seen, but with slipping margins some changes are likely.



Monday, 6 April 2009

Consumers and the Credit Crunch - Latest Views on Food Buying Behaviour


In the words of Justin King of Sainsbury, speaking during a business performance update last week - “the consumer is in a bad place just now”. Which is not really surprising, given the amount of depressing economic news.

Nevertheless, both Sainsbury and Morrisons, who also gave a business update last week, feel that food is one of the last things where consumers are prepared to trade down. A view echoed by the IGD (Institute of Grocery Distribution) who say their research indicates that “Economising is not the same as down trading”. Sainsbury’s “Basics” range is indeed up 60% year on year, but it still accounts for only 3% of total sales. Sales of their premium “Taste the Difference” range are “off the pace”, which is corporate speak for falling, but the range is still 2.5x as big as Basics, and the sales decline is attributed to a drop in the market for ready meals, rather than a flight from quality. Morrisons “The Best” premium range is up by 5.3%
So there is still a search for good food, and a Times Populus survey (26th March) put quality as equal to value for money when it comes to choosing a store. But its not quality at any price. Instead, people are far pickier about what they buy and energetic about finding the best deals.

The search for good deals is leading to much shopping around. The days of convenient one stop shopping have given way to two and even three stop shopping and both Morrisons and Sainsbury claim an increase in numbers of shoppers in their stores. What this suggests is that the traditional way of categorising stores is dead. No longer can we say Sainsbury and Waitrose upmarket, ASDA and Morrisons downmarket, and Tesco in the middle. Its much more individual than that now with each shopper asking whether the quality /value equation at a particular store at a particular time is right for them. Looking at the crystal ball I’d say that the next big strategic challenge from supermarkets will be how to build loyalty. Meanwhile value offers will become increasingly innovative.

Once in the store, what the shopper buys is changing. The aforementioned ready meals market is plummeting, and TNS (Taylor Nelson Sofres) the market research company tells us that frozen foods are growing by over 9% year on year, enjoying a change in status from poor relation to a wise choice due to cheaper prices and far less waste.

The IGD as well as the supermarkets tell us that there’s a lot more cooking from scratch going on, apparently herbs and fresh pasta are flying off the shelves in Morrisons. And there is a return to families eating together.

There are mixed views about whether ethical purchasing is taking a back seat. The decline in the organic market has been reported to death (sales down 15% in the last three months, bread down 31%, vegetables down 10% according to TNS), but as is being acknowledged even by the Soil Association, the issue here is that consumers can’t get their heads around why organics in general are worth a premium. Animal welfare issues though remain important to consumers. Sainsbury stressed again last week that this is something shoppers search for, and IGD research confirms it. The question of course is where this welcome concern about animal welfare will go next and there are reports that Hugh Fearnley Whittingstall is turning his attention to dairy cattle.

So in summary, the recession is leading to changes in what and how shoppers buy. They are not prepared though to sacrifice quality, and will shop around to get it at the right price. Equally they are prepared to support ethical products where they clearly understand what it is that they are paying for.

Thursday, 4 December 2008

Tesco Outgunned by the Competition - Some Reasons Why

So Tesco is getting outgunned by the competition. Third quarter results show their sales up by a miserable 2% compared with Sainsbury up 4.3%, ASDA up 6.9% and Morrisons up 8.1%.

The root cause is customer defection. An analysis by TNS the market research company, shows that in the 12 weeks to November, Tesco lost about £22 million of business to ASDA, a further £10million ALDI and just under £10million to Morrisons . Clearly "every little helps" is not helping enough. Why might this be?

There seem to be three reasons.

First, Tesco has a muddled consumer message compared with competitors. ASDA and Morrisons are known as value supermarkets. ALDI screams rock bottom prices. Sainsbury have stuck with a quality message. Tesco by contrast have responded to the economic downturn by adding a number of discount type products similar to those sold by ALDI and the like, but done little with their main ranges. So in the shopper's mind they are offering neither the cheap prices of an ALDI, or consistent value across everything in store like ASDA and Morrisons. And a slogan like "every little helps" means little to cash strapped consumers keen to hit a budget but reluctant to buy rubbish.

Tesco's prices are too high, and their quality too low. How do we know this? Just read the comments left by shoppers on newspaper articles about Tesco's performance. They tell of huge price hikes, inconsistent prices from week to week, promotions advertised but no product available in store to buy, and inferior fresh products such as bakery and fruit and veg.

And most telling of all, Tesco seems to have forgotten about putting customers first. Customers are outraged at Tesco's arrogant attitude and lack of service.

I'd also add that resentment about the way they treat suppliers is reaching boiling point. At the moment lack of facts means their alleged practices tend not to hit the headlines. This will change if Tesco is demonstrated to cross the line between tough negotiation and outright intimidation, and the publicity will do them little good.

There are lessons for all businesses from the Tesco story.

Successful businesses have a very clear marketing message, and they stick with it. Their actual product offer is often fine tuned, but they do not stray from their basic core principles. And they never, ever, take their customers for granted.

No one would bet against Tesco which is one of the most succesful businesses in Britain. Despite a slowdown in sales they remain almost twice as big as their nearest competitor, and their discount range is turning over about £1billion, which is nearly the same as ALDI's total sales. But they are not invincible, and if they don't learn the lessons then their performance will struggle.






Friday, 12 September 2008

Food Buying Habits - How, When, and Why Did It All Change?


Food shopping habits have changed. Consumers are changing where they shop, how they shop, and what they buy.


Morrisons, home of low prices, and Waitrose at the premium end of the scale, both published half year results a couple of days ago. Morrisons grew like for like sales by 7.6%, (like for like meaning sales in stores open at least a year), and profits by 19%. Waitrose grew sales by 2.5%, a third of the rate of Morrisons, were forced to cut some prices to compete and hold market share, and saw profits fall by 8%. ALDI, viewed as having the cheapest prices of the lot, is now said to be growing sales at about 30% versus last year. A confident statement from ASDA a few weeks ago indicated that they are doing just fine because they offer really low prices. And Sainsbury and the once the once invulnerable Tesco are losing out.


Consumers are changing what they buy. We know that organic sales are struggling, reportedly down 20% in August versus last year, that meat consumption is down 5% according to the latest figures published on the British Pig Executive website, and DairyCo says that milk consumption is down. Consumers are also buying more products in retailer's Value ranges. Morrisons showed a chart at their results presentation illustrating that across the whole of the grocery trade Value ranges were growing at about 8% in the spring, but have now rocketed to a growth of nearly 30%. By contrast Premium ranges growth has fallen from a high of 15% in March 08 to around 3% in August.


Other startling changes are happening. Sainsbury tell us that between July and August sales of tupperware containers have grown by 36%, and sandwich bags by 35%, as more people take sandwiches to work instead of buying ready made.


All in all, it seems that beleaguered Brits are leaving no stone unturned in an effort to spend less. The interesting thing though, is that although the credit crunch started almost a year ago with the Northern Rock wobble, the big changes in what and where people buy only started in the spring. Going back to Waitrose as an example, they were sailing along quite nicely until early summer.


Why the drop since then? Because that's when consumer confidence started to plummet,worn away by headlines about food price inflation, spikes in oil prices, mortgage worries, and warnings of rising energy bills Another chart from Morrisons shows that in March, consumers confidence levels were down by 18%, in August they were down by 40%. Or to put it another way, nearly half the country thinks things are going to get worse, much worse. If they are that worried, it's no wonder people are changing behaviour, battening down the hatches, and bracing themselves for what might be around the next corner.


What is clear though, is that doom mongers who say they always knew that all people want is cheap food are wrong. Despite the belt tightening, Premium sales are still growing albeit at a slower rate than previously. It does not look either as if shoppers are ditching ethical principles altogether. Waitrose says that consumers are still supporting welfare friendly food but choosing free range rather than organic to save some money. ASDA says its sales of organic produce have grown by 25%, and Morrisons reported that their sales of both Fair Trade and organic sales are growing.


As ever, it does seem as if those who offer good quality combined with good value (which is not the same thing as price) will ride out the storm, ready for an upturn in confidence.

Friday, 30 May 2008

Supermarket Sales Show Strong Growth, No Sign of Consumer Cutbacks

Taylor Nelson Sofres (TNS) has published grocery sales growth and market share figures for the 12 weeks to May 16th. They show no signs of a consumer cutback. Total sales are up 6.6%, with big share gains for Morrisons (sales up 8.7%) and ASDA (up 7.6%) at the expense of Sainsbury (up 4.6%) and Tesco (up 6%). Somerfield and the Coop continue to lose share, and independent stores are holding up well.

The much talked about growth in sales through cheaper priced discount stores seems to be more about shoppers at the now defunct Kwiksave seeking a similar type of store rather than a consumer flight to cheaper shopping. The total market share held by discounters last year was 5.7% and it is still 5.7% . At the other end of the scale, up market Waitrose held a 3.9% share both last year and this, indicating that consumers are still buying premium food. Overall, the only hint of a change is a small share growth for Iceland which sells lower priced frozen food.
The actual share numbers for 2008, with 2007 in brackets, are as follows:
%
Tesco 31.1 (31.3)

Asda 16.9 (16.7)

Sainsbury 16.0 (16.3)

Morrisons 11.4 (11.2)

Somerfield 3.7 (3.8)

Kwiksave 0.0 (0.2)

Waitrose 3.9 (3.9)

Iceland 1.7 (1.6)

Netto 0.6 (0.7)

Lidl 2.3 (2.3)

Aldi 2.8 (2.3)

Co-ops 4.5 4.3

Other Multiples 1.6 1.7

Independents 2.8 2.8