Wednesday, 29 September 2010

Supermarket Watch - How Sainsbury and Waitrose Got it Right but ASDA Didn't

Americans call it “The Big Mo” and it means that happy state when a business has momentum - the team is winning, confidence is brimming over, and whatever is being done is a huge success. Sainsbury, with 19 consecutive quarters of growth under their belts have it, Waitrose, currently the fastest growing supermarket have it, but ASDA whose sales have dropped month after month for nearly a year, most certainly do not have it.

Confidence about doing the right thing and doing it well is illustrated by the way these three supermarkets have executed their recent new initiatives. Sainsbury have revamped their premium “Taste the Difference” range with trading director Mike Coupe claiming that “this is the best range of premium food available in any supermarket”. At the other end of the scale Waitrose is trumpeting value credentials by saying they will match the Tesco’s price on 1000 major brands. In the middle, ASDA have announced the launch of “Chosen by You” which is a quality upgrade of their standard range, with products selected after talking to 40,000 people across the UK.
So here are three major activities, but it’s the way they have been executed which marks out Sainsbury and Waitrose as confident winners, and ASDA as an outfit that, temporarily at least, has lost its way.

Sainsbury’s have made sure that food shoppers across Britain know about the new range. They took out three and sometimes four page advertisements in the papers, are running a TV ad with Jamie Oliver, and are giving away glossy leaflets in store. Customers who shop on line get a message about the new range as soon as they click on to the website. Waitrose also took out three page advertisements, are advertising on TV, and have the price cut message when shoppers click on the website. They have put up big displays of the newly priced products in their shops, pinned up labels on the shelves, and just in case the message has still been missed, the dividers shoppers put on the checkout belt to signify the start of their shopping also mention the price cuts.

And what about ASDA? The range was launched on September 21st, but on a trip to the Leamington store today I saw only a couple of overhead posters talking about the range - easy to miss as few shoppers were walking around staring at the ceiling. There were no displays, no markers at the shelves, and no in store tasting sessions. There have been no advertisements, and when clicking on to the website the first message is that prices are low, the second that there is 15% off furniture, and only the third talks about “Chosen by You”.

Possibly ASDA don’t feel that the new launch is that big a deal, but this seems unlikely as their recently promoted MD has made a point of criticising the quality of its food, and in the press release that accompanied the launch he talks about ASDA now driving as hard on quality as it does on price. More probably, the launch smacks of a company that has lost its edge, cannot decide what its main message is, and forgotten the attention to detail that is vital. Retail is detail as someone once said. The ASDA approach It is a big contrast to the super- confident actions of Sainsbury and Waitrose.

Sunday, 19 September 2010

Wiseman's Profits Warning - Deja Vu All Over Again

Robert Wiseman’s profits warning shocked investors who promptly knocked 30% off the share price. The problem, says the company, is “intense competitive pressures across all sectors of the market”, and so they are reducing second half profit expectations by £7m, and 2011 by £16m.

The background has been well documented. Basically a price war has broken out on milk, with ASDA starting the fight, and Tesco promptly retaliating. The cost is being borne by processors, and the situation is seemingly exacerbated by smaller dairies being prepared to cut prices to gain more volume.

The most surprising thing about this announcement is that everyone is so surprised. Wiseman has a history of profit problems due to negotiations with the big supermarkets. In May 2005 the Group warned that profits had fallen by 15% versus the prior year due to losing a contract with ASDA. In May 2008, the company warned that profits would take a hit of £8.5m because it was taking longer than anticipated to get retailers to agree to price rises which were needed to cover escalating costs.

Here it all goes again, and with the firm’s current business model, profit performance will continue to be volatile.

The big issue with Wiseman is that it sells one product, fresh milk, and is reliant on one distribution channel, the major supermarkets. It has nowhere to go if things get difficult – no other product sectors, no major brands, and few other sales outlets. Unlike its competitors Arla, and Dairy Crest, the latter rushing out an announcement of their own saying that they expected full year profits to come in as forecast. They did admit though that the fresh milk market was proving challenging.

The optimist would point to Wiseman’s cash generating ability, and a good record on cost reduction. Unfortunately neither seems to be enough to protect against supermarket whims and power.

Wednesday, 8 September 2010

Reviving Organic Food - The Waitrose Way



We can now see how Waitrose will handle Duchy Originals, the brand pioneered by the Prince of Wales, and moved into partnership with Waitrose 12 months ago. And the plans show impressive commitment to the organic market and the ideal of supporting sustainable food from small family farms which motivated the Prince when he started the company 20 years ago.

Basically, Waitrose is using Duchy as their organic brand, featured on a raft of products, from staples such as milk, eggs and frozen foods, to fancier products like Handmade Organic Hafod Welsh Cheddar. According to Waitrose there are plans to increase the range to 400 products.
The launch of “Duchy Originals by Waitrose” has been heralded by advertisements in the papers, a TV spot featuring Heston Blumenthal, and a 25% introductory price cut to tempt shoppers to buy. None of this comes cheap and it shows that Waitrose are deadly serious about the potential of organic food.

It’s not just the commitment to organics which is interesting (and should give producers soldiering on with the sector despite a big drop in consumer demand some cause for optimism). It’s the way that Waitrose have approached the market. Clearly the company has decided that calling a product organic is not in itself a sufficient reason for consumers to pay the organic premium. Consumers want something more, and Waitrose feel that by adding the prestigious Duchy name, and explaining the values which lie behind it, they are giving people that extra bit of reassurance and motivation to choose the more expensive option.

There may be another reason for Waitrose’s organic commitment. In a previous blog I suggested that supermarkets might be turning their attention to super- premium foods again to offset the costs of heavy price cutting on everyday items, a problem which is only going to get worse as food inflation strikes once more. Organic food is an obvious premium market for Waitrose to develop as they already hold a 21% share of the sector, but only a 4% share of the total grocery market.

Whatever the reasons, it would be great if the Waitrose move works. Many Duchy suppliers are small, and a foothold in the company will help grow sales. With the Prince keeping a close eye on things, they should get a fair return too.

Thursday, 19 August 2010

Sales Fall Again at ASDA - Cheap Prices are not Compensating for Poor Quality


Here’s another confirmation that consumers do not just buy food purely on the basis of price. Mysupermarket.com the price comparison website says that ASDA is the cheapest of the “Big Four” (ASDA,Tesco, Sainsbury, Morrisons), yet ASDA yesterday announced that like for like sales fell by 0.4% in the three months to July 31st, after a 0.3% fall in the three months before that. At the same time Kantar Worldpanel, the research company which reports on how supermarkets are faring, said that ASDA continues to lose market share, whilst Morrisons and Sainsbury motor ahead.
Commenting on the company’s performance, Andy Clarke, ASDA’s new chief executive was vocal on the subject of price being different from value. Saying “We have got to be the best value. What we have been is the best price”, he promised that in future customers would see a “step change” in quality - “We are not as well known for the quality of our food as we could be”.
Despite this commitment to better products, Clarke also said that UK consumers are facing difficult times, that ASDA would respond by offering everyday low prices, and that as a first step towards this goal, ASDA would cut the price of staples such as bread, milk, and eggs.

He is not alone in recognising that as well as offering great quality, supermarkets have to offer sharp prices to ensure that shoppers walk through their doors as opposed to competitors. Even Waitrose, store of choice for the affluent, recognises this and anyone venturing in to a Waitrose will see aisle ends featuring promotional offers. In fact all supermarkets with the exception of ASDA are heavily price promoting with Kantar reporting that nearly 35% of all products are bought on promotion compared with 31% a year ago.

The focus on price is unlikely to ease any time soon. Consumer confidence has taken a bit of a dive recently as the scale of government cutbacks is becoming clearer, and they seem less willing to spend. Whilst this has yet to happen in supermarkets where sales in the last 12 weeks grew by 4.5%, supermarket supremos will be turning their attention to driving growth against a background of consumer thrift.

So how will they make money when heavy promotions lead to lower profits, and shoppers demand good quality? Harder bargains will be struck with suppliers of course. But a more productive answer might lie in developing a new “super premium” market segment with even higher cash margins than current premium ranges, and with a quality so irresistible that shoppers are happy to buy. We know that even in the depths of recession, consumers were prepared to spend on top quality goods if they felt they were worth the money.

Innovative suppliers who can deliver superb quality products at an acceptable return to themselves and their supermarket stockists could do well. Not easy though.

Tuesday, 10 August 2010

How Do You Solve a Problem Like Falling Lamb Consumption - Thoughts from Sheep 2010

There was standing room only for the session on marketing at last week's NSA event where farmer Geoffrey Probert, May Hill representative Henry Dunn, Remi Fourrier from EBLEX, and Steve McClean of Marks and Spencer discussed a variety of issues.

The problem of plummeting lamb eating in the home market was addressed, and the general concensus was that quality is fine, its all about price.

For Remi Fourrier, who is responsible for growing British lamb sales to France from it current one in 5 lambs produced, the main issue is encouraging younger people to eat lamb, and that ways had to be found to make lamb more convenient to cook.

Henry Dunn, representing May Hill who sell to Sainsbury, pointed to the success of Cotswold Lamb which he feels works because it has a strong provenance story. Consumers like the idea of knowing where their lamb has come from and how it was produced. Steve McClean agreed. Marks and Spencer shoppers are interested in provenance too, and increasingly in the impact of products on the environment. M&S are planning to add more environmental compliance measures into the standards it requires from producers.

All mentioned that consumers of ethnic origin eat large quantities of sheep meat - a figure of 27% was quoted, but all recognised the sensitivity of slaughter procedures required by some.

Returning to the quality issue, there were a couple of comments about grass fed lamb producing a top quality product. This was considered to be one of the reasons behind New Zealand lamb's good and consistent quality. Marks and Spencer source from NZ in our winter, and aim for grass fed lamb in summer for this reason. As Mr. McClean said "It's all about ensuring consumers have a good eating experience when they buy lamb".

So no silver bullets emerged from the debate.

As a firm believer that, whatever the product, price is a problem if the quality does not match up, I was surprised that quality and consistency of lamb did not get more of an airing.

A look at WorldPanel numbers supplied by BPEX shows that in the 12 weeks to July 11th, lamb sales dropped by a further 8%. So the problem of what to do about falling lamb sales is not going away.

Thursday, 29 July 2010

Keeping the Farming Flag Flying

Matthew Naylor in his Farmers Weekly Mouth of the Wash blog, is urging peace between environmental enthusiasts both in and out with farming, and it inspired me to tackle the British Trust for Ornithology who were quoted in an article in this week's Sunday Times which accused farmers of getting paid to allow bird numbers to decline. Usually I'd have dismissed such a report with a tut and a " typical" and turned the page.

But not this time. It was on to the BTO to request the survey information to which the article alluded, and to make the point that it would be far more productive if we all worked together to preserve the environment and avoid scoring cheap points in the press.

The BTO's response in the shape of Dr. Gavin Siriwardena could not have been more different from that of the RSPB in the previous week. Commenting on one part of the same survey which showed reductions in the number of kestrels, the RSPB engaged mouth before brain, blamed intensive farming practices, and overall could not have been much more hostile.

Dr. Siriwardena by contrast went to great lengths to explain the BTO's research, and forwarded the newsletter which had been produced, which to be fair was far more balanced than the Sunday Times' heavily spun take. Importantly he recognised that too often there is a "them and us" feeling between farming and non farming environmentalists, and stressed the BTO's committment to working in unity.

Things have moved on, and today DEFRA released the BTO's survey results. I see that the RSPB is taking a much more even handed tone, possibly reacting to a barrage of outrage from their previous comments.


And the moral of the story?

What cannot be denied is that the decline in farmland bird populations is worrying to put it mildly. It needs a concerted and unified approach to sorting out the problems, with energy put into solutions rather than sniping. Some, like the BTO, have recognised this.

There are many farmers working diligently to improve the environment. It is time consuming, often financially draining, and usually happens without acknowledgement. Their efforts need to be communicated, but the only people who can spread the farming message are farmers themselves. No one else is going to do it.

Matthew quotes Heather and Phil Gorringe who upon hearing of the RSPB's comments about kestrels orchestrated a Twitter campaign to show what farmers are doing for the environment. Twittering may not be every farmers cup of tea, but the idea of making an effort to communicate the good things being done, and to challenge unfair attacks, looks like a pretty sound one.

Friday, 23 July 2010

Ocado Looks Like NOcado, at Least for Now

As of 3.00pm Friday 23rd July shares in Ocado, the online grocery delivery company, were trading at £1.55p. Well down on Wednesday's opening price of £1.80p and a country mile from the £2.72 - £2.00p that its ex Goldman Sachs owners touted as the company's value on Tuesday evening.

£1.55p still values Ocado at around £500 million, and the mystery is why anyone should think that a business which has never made a profit in its 8 years of trading, has an unproven business model, is competing with grocery giants like Tesco, and is fighting head to head with Waitrose who supply Ocado's products but who are also seeking to build an online offering, can be worth even that.

The optimists would point to Ocado's massive top line growth. They would cite projections that online grocery shopping will double in size to £7.2bn or about 5% of total grocery sales by 2014 (IGD research). And they would say that online retailers such as Amazon struggled to make a profit when they started out.

The Goldman Sachs founders would also add that they own world beating sophisticated technology, and that American investors who account for nearly 60% of shareholdings "get" this, whereas the Brits do not.

It should also be noted that, despite adverse comments in the press, Ocado's own customers were confident enough to invest between £5 and £10m of their own money in the company, and whilst customer investment was expected to be much higher (up to about £60million), this could say something about the quality of the Ocado offer versus competition. These customers have the chance to offload their shares at the original price of £1.80p and it will be interesting to see how many do so.

This blog was very sceptical about Ocado way back in March, and remains sceptical. It would be great to be proved wrong and find that a British business could succeed due to a genuinely different consumer offer backed by technological innovation.

We shall watch with interest.