Monday, 16 February 2009

Livestock and the Environment - Where is the Voice of Farming?




Livestock and the environment are in the spotlight again, and the frustrating thing for anyone involved in food or farming is the one sided nature of the debate. All the media coverage boils down to one message – “meat and dairy environmentally bad so eat less”. We hear little about the food value of the products, the role that livestock plays in keeping Britain’s countryside beautiful, or the steps that agriculture is taking to reduce its environmental impact. The headlines are worrying because a cut back in consumption will eventually affect the price paid to farmers for their products, and it is difficult to understand why the industry seems voiceless and invisible.

Capturing most headlines is the proposal by the NHS to cut back on the amount of meat it serves to patients. This, they say, will help reduce their carbon footprint, and will be beneficial to the long term health of patients. Whilst those with sick loved ones might worry about whether recovery will be as quick without the benefit of a balanced diet, and the cynic might wonder whether the driving force is to reduce NHS costs, nonetheless the fact is that the NHS serves up millions of meals and such a move will impact meat sales.

Less headline grabbing is the report “Food Futures” by think tank Chatham House.
Read the detail and you see a real anti meat and dairy bias. Meat and dairy are blamed for health issues. Global agriculture is said to be responsible for 14% of non carbon greenhouse gas emissions, and that a third of this is due to livestock. And they quote an EU report which says that meat and dairy are the main source of green house gas emissions in the food and drink sector. They trot out the old statistic that a kilo of grain fed beef requires 15 cubic metres of water versus cereals which require between 0.3 and 4 cubic metres, forgetting to mention that most livestock in the UK is pasture fed. Most alarming of all, the Chatham House solution is for government to dictate what we can and cannot eat, saying “The food system will need to reflect society’s choices as much as individual preferences”.

Then last week at the Meat and Livestock Commission’s Outlook conference a speaker from the Food Climate Research Network said that eating meat had to become more environmentally viable either by the industry reducing emissions or people eating less meat. She said that a meat tax might help and that there were moves to add the cost of emissions to the price of a food in order to encourage consumers to rethink what they are buying.

Fortunately a more balanced view of things emerged at the same conference in the shape of Mike Coupe, trading director of Sainsbury who said that cutting carbon emissions by limiting food choice is a “form of communism”, and that a tax would be unlikely to change people’s meat consumption unless it was huge.

The key point is that the issue of agriculture and climate change is not going to go away.

Few will dispute the need to take climate change seriously. But the debate is totally one-sided. Consumers not getting a balanced message about the value of meat and dairy products and the livestock which supply them.

So what should be done?

In a nutshell, simple fact backed messages must be communicated regularly and by independent, respected sources as well as the industry itself. A one off burst of activity just will not work.

There are three messages to convey

1. Meat and dairy are high protein foods, containing vitamins and minerals essential to good health. As the Food Standards Agency says "Meat is a good source of protein and vitamins and minerals, such as iron, selenium, zinc, and B vitamins. It is one of the main sources of vitamin B12, which is only found in foods from animals, such as meat and milk.”

The FSA also says “ Milk and dairy products such as cheese, yoghurt and fromage frais are great sources of protein and vitamins A and B 12 . They're also an important source of calcium, which helps to keep our bones strong. The calcium in dairy foods are easy for the body to absorb”.

2. Without cattle and sheep grazing the hills and moors our countryside would become overgrown in just a few years

3. Livestock farming has a plan to reduce greenhouse gases. (Assuming it does have a plan of course. A trawl through websites from the NFU, Dairyco, the NBA and the NSA does not turn up an easy to read summary of how the industry is tackling climate change. Contrast this with the National Cattlemens' Beef Association of America page on beef cattle and the environment.)

Funding for the information campaign can be found from any number of places. For a start I’d suggest ditching the Red Tractor and redirecting the levy funds, on the grounds that the Tractor means no more to the average consumer than a Union Jack.

Then, what about forensically examining the evidence that Meaty and Lamby are persuading people to buy more meat. Would the funds be better spent supporting a targeted campaign.

The big question is why the industry is not doing more about an issue which has been on the table for years, and which is growing in importance.

Monday, 2 February 2009

Animal Welfare - What Does the Public Really Think?



Animal welfare issues are again in the news.

Last week alone saw Hugh Fearnley Whittingstall take on Tesco in the cause of truthful labelling on chicken, Jamie Oliver supporting British pigs, a concerted advertising campaign by Sainsbury promoting their Freedom Foods pork, chicken, and salmon, and news of their ban on caged eggs. We also heard that Tracy, marchioness of Worcester has done a programme advocating better pig welfare, to be screened tonight.

On the other hand, last week also saw a piece by Andy Bond of ASDA in The Grocer claiming that worrying about animal welfare is yesterday’s agenda, and that celebrity chefs are patronising cash strapped consumers. Waitrose who have for years promoted high animal welfare standards seem to be losing sales, and organic meat products, which support high welfare, have apparently seen a big sales drop in the last three months.

So do consumers care?

The facts suggest that many already care enough to have changed how they shop, and that the more information they are given about the issue, the more prepared they are to change. It’s by no means everybody, and even the worried have limits on how much they are prepared to pay, but there is a growing movement to higher welfare products.

IGD research continues to find this. They say that whilst price has increased in importance as a factor influencing shopping habits, the number of consumers who have specifically bought foods with high animal welfare standards has increased from 11% in 2007 to 18% in 2009. They also point out that use of free range eggs has now moved to processed foods such as mayonnaise and pasta.

TNS the market research group in a survey commissioned by Compassion in World Farming have reported that free range chicken sales grew by 35%, and higher welfare sales by 42%, between December 2007 and December 2008. They also say that in December alone, standard chicken sales dropped by 11% in total and by 55% in Tesco. Free range, higher welfare and organic chickens now account for about 15% of sales, still small, but growing fast.

On to pigs. Jamie’s programme attracted 1.9 million viewers, less than the 3 million for his chicken programme, but nevertheless a sizable audience. It is early to judge whether it has made a difference although Waitrose have reported that their sales of pork (all British of course) rose by 20% following the programme.

It looks as if Andy Bond’s sweeping statement that consumers are not prepared to pay for higher welfare products is just not true, and if we are talking patronising, then for Bond to lump all his customers into one box and not recognise that people have different priorities, pressures and values, seems patronising in the extreme.

Most supermarkets, even Tesco and ASDA have acknowledged the trend and sell a higher welfare chicken to help the conscience stricken but cash strapped consumer.

Sainsbury have introduced a Freedom Food endorsed option costing about £1.50 more for the average bird, but with a clear explanation of the better rearing conditions. Sainsbury have also kept their range of basics, free range and organic for those who want alternatives.

They are adopting the same approach on pork. Again, it’s Freedom Food endorsed, again there is an explanation of why it is better for the pigs, and the extra price is small at about 50p per kilo more than standard.

Where will the animal welfare issue go from here? I feel that as awareness of how farmed animals are raised grows, consumers will increasingly look for higher welfare options. It may take years, and it will require commitment from well known respected champions like Hugh and Jamie who will not be put off by vested interests coming down on them like the proverbial ton of bricks, and equally will seek out the full facts before acting. It was a bit depressing for example that Jamie in his admirable support for British pigs did not mention that there are still some unsavoury yet legal pig raising conditions here such as housing the animals on slats. But you have to start somewhere.

There is evidence too that animal welfare concerns could extend to other species. The long running Anchor advertisements for butter from “free range cows”, with the implication that not all cows run freely in the sunshine as consumers would like to believe, would be an example of a company, foreign at that, spotting both the trend towards higher welfare.

Finally, it is not too difficult to imagine that better welfare conditions become such an issue that supermarkets decide to raise the bar for producers yet refuse to pay more.



























claiming that worrying about animal welfare is yesterday’s agenda, and that celebrity chefs are patronising cash strapped consumers, and a concerted advertising campaign by Sainsbury promoting their Freedom Foods pork and chicken, and their ban on caged eggs. This week Tracy, Marchioness of Worcester, will be seen on More 4 TV in the cause of pigs. Meanwhile Waitrose who have for years promoted high animal welfare standards seem to be losing sales, and organic products, which also promote high welfare, have seen a big sales drop in the last three months.

So do consumers care? The facts suggest that many already care enough to have changed how they shop, and that the more information they are given about the issue, the more prepared they are to change. It’s by no means everybody, and even the worried have limits on how much they are prepared to pay, but there is a growing movement to higher welfare products.

The IGD continues to find this. They say that whilst price has increased in importance as a factor influencing shopping habits, the number of consumers who have specifically bought foods with high animal welfare standards has increased from 11% in 2007 to 18% in 2009. They also point out that use of free range eggs has now moved to processed foods such as mayonnaise and pasta.

TNS the market research group in a survey commissioned by Compassion in World Farming have reported that free range chicken sales grew by 35%, and higher welfare sales by 42%, between December 2007 and December 2008. They also indicated that in December alone, standard sales dropped by 11% in total and by 55% in Tesco. It should be said though that the percentage of sales in free range, higher welfare and organic remains small.

On to pigs. Jamie’s programme attracted 1.9 million viewers, less than the xx for his chicken programme, but nevertheless respectable. It is early to see whether it has made a difference although Waitrose have reported that their sales of pork (all British of course) rose by 20% following the programme.

It looks as if Andy Bond’s sweeping statement that “xxxxx” is just not true, and if we are talking patronising, then for Bond to lump all his customers into one box and not recognise that people have different priorities, pressures and values, seems patronising in the extreme.

Sainsbury have spotted the trend, and have been very shrewd in the way that they have tackled the issue. In an effort to help the conscience stricken but cash strapped shopper, they have introduced Freedom Food endorsed, higher welfare chicken with a clear explanation of why it is better for the birds. It does cost more but only about xxxx a kilo, or £ for an average bird. They have also kept their range of basics, free range and organic for those who want an alternative.

They are adopting the same approach on pork. Again, it’s Freedom Food endorsed, again there is an explanation of why it is better for the pigs, and again, the extra price is small.

Where will the animal welfare issue go from here? I feel that as awareness of how farmed animals are raised grows, consumers will increasingly look for higher welfare options. It may take years, and it will require commitment from well known respected champions like Hugh and Jamie who will not be put off by vested interests coming down on them like the proverbial ton of bricks, and equally will seek out the full facts before acting. It was a bit depressing for example that Jamie in his admirable support for British pigs did not mention that there are still some unsavoury yet legal pig raising conditions here such as housing the animals on slats. But you have to start somewhere.

There is evidence too that others are looking at animal welfare conditions from a different angle. The long running Anchor advertisements for butter from “free range cows” would be an example.

Finally, it is not too difficult to imagine that better welfare conditions become such an issue that supermarkets decide to raise the bar for producers yet refuse to pay more.
























Friday, 23 January 2009

Dragons Den’s Evan Davis on the Secrets of Successful Entrepreneurship

After 4 years hosting Dragons Den Evan Davis probably knows more than most about entrepreneurs. At a conference in December held at the Royal Agricultural College on the topic of "Inspiring Entrepreneurship" in agribusiness, he described the 5 characteristics he feels all successful entrepreneurs possess.

1. Optimism
This is the key requirement. Successful entrepreneurs possess an optimism “bordering on the delusional”. Those who make it see the glass half full all the time, they are never put off by obstacles thrown in their way, and bounce back after the hardest of knocks.

2. The ability to spot how things could be done better
The good entrepreneur has the knack of spotting the irritations in life’s everyday activities, and working out how they could be removed or reduced. Evan advised would-be entrepreneurs to make a point every day of finding two products or services which could be improved.

Equally entrepreneurs can see ways to create opportunities. He gave as an example the couple who developed cardboard beach furniture, but decided that the most lucrative route was to sell the opportunity to brand the furniture, rather than sell the furniture itself. Their product ended up on Henman Hill at Wimbledon, carrying the logo of a well known company.

3. The energy to make things happen
Being highly creative is on its own not enough, great entrepreneurs come out of the clouds, get their shirt sleeves rolled up, and work out the nuts and bolts of putting their ideas into practice.

4. Basic business knowledge
And, in the same vein, they have basic business skills. They can write a business plan, and understand costs and cash flows. This skill often clashes with their optimism resulting in wildly overblown projections, but the successful entrepreneur can temper the optimism with reality.

5. Willingness to adapt and change
The best entrepreneurs have tested their ideas thoroughly on potential customers, not just mum and dad, or sympathetic friends. They have listened to feedback, and adjusted their idea accordingly.

Despite all those skills an entrepreneur’s idea may not get off the ground, and even if it does, may not fly for long for all sorts of reasons. The most successful business people can catch a cold as the recent failure of green haulier JPM Eco Logistics which received investment from Dragons Deborah Meaden and Theo Paphitis showed.

But that’s presumably where the optimism comes back in. The best entrepreneurs just dust themselves down and get going again, regardless.

Friday, 16 January 2009

Dairy Products Market 2008


Here’s a look at the Dairy Products market in 2008, courtesy of the Grocer. All data is for the 12 months to end October, and supplied by Nielsen market research.

It was a year when huge jumps in food prices collided with credit-crunched consumers reining in spending. Unsurprisingly there were changes in how people shopped for dairy products, but not perhaps as many as might be imagined.

Consumers bought roughly the same volume of products, despite dairy price inflation of 13.4%. There was some trading down to own label, notably in the butters and spreads sector, but by and large the big well advertised and promoted brands held on to their positions with the weaker ones struggling. There was a turning away from products sold as functional or fortified, with the exception of Danone Activia with its promise of a revved up digestive system. And Organic slipped back but is not yet in freefall.

Butters and Spreads
Total value sales were up by 17% to £1.1bn, with own label growing almost twice as fast, up 31%
Total volume sales were down by 1.1%, but own label grew by 4.3%.
A couple of grocery trade spokespeople commented that spreadable butters are growing fast because they combine convenience with a natural and healthy product. By contrast fortified spreads are losing sales because consumers are confused about why they should buy them, and they are more expensive.
Perhaps echoing the natural message, Lurpak butter is the number one brand for the second year running, beating Flora.
This is a sector where organic is struggling with Yeo Valley’s value sales up by only 6% in a market where inflation was 13%, meaning that volume sales must have been well down.

Cheese
Total value sales grew by 11.5% to £2.2bn. Own label grew slightly faster, up 11.8%
Its good to see that Cathedral City, is still the biggest brand in the market, owned by Dairy Crest, and British of course.

And a cheer for Wyke Farms which grew by 30% and is now the eighth biggest cheese brand. Here’s hoping that it is making money, and continues to show that it is possible to compete with multinational companies.

Yogurts
Total value sales were up by 7.7% to £1.9bn, and volumes grew by 1%. This is one category where own label is not growing as fast as branded products.
According to the Waitrose buyer consumers are flocking to Natural and Greek yogurts because they are seen as healthier.
Organic yogurt Rachel’s Dairy bucked the organic downturn and grew by 14%, but Yeo Valley clocked up a 1% growth.

Yogurt Drinks
This market is struggling. Value sales despite inflation were down 2.6%, and volume sales down by 8.3%.
The buyer for Booth’s supermarkets reckons that this is a market where consumers are cutting back because of price.

Fresh Milk (Additional data from DairyCo)
The total fresh milk market grew by 14.1% in value to £3.2bn, and 0.6% in volume. People are still purchasing as much fresh milk as they ever did.
Filtered milk, led by Cravendale continued to grow, up by 29%, but the modified milk market is fast disappearing, down by 35%, and is another example of consumers resisting a natural product which has been tampered with.
The Organic milk market was stable and Yeo Valley grew by 46%. There is anecdotal evidence that mothers like to buy organic milk for young children, even though it costs more than standard.
Wiseman’s “The One” milk did well growing by 48%.


NB

The one thing to bear in mind when looking at these numbers is that they are for the 12 months ending October 2008, about when recession truly started to bite. A look at data for the last quarter of 2008 may show some differences.

Tuesday, 6 January 2009

The Food Consumer 2009

Tis the season for predictions, and whilst the cynical might feel that forecasting in today's volatile climate has as much chance of accuracy as Mystic Meg, a trawl of what the pundits are saying is showing alot of concensus about where consumers are headed.


Here are the key themes.

1. Paying down debt.

Spurred on by fears of losing their job, and the dawning realisation that even if employed they are living well beyond their means, consumers are determined to reduce their debt, by spending the minimum possible. They are thinking hard about what they really need, and what product benefits they think are worth paying for.

As strategy consultants Marakon put it, this means a big gap between the features of many products and what consumers truly value. In other words, anything over priced for what it is, or where a perfectly good cheaper alternative exists, will see plummeting sales. Organic products, many premium foods and drinks, and pretentious restaurants selling substandard food at inflated prices will come under an increasingly harsh spotlight.



2. Searching for security and emotional comfort

The gloom and doom is bringing with it a yearning for security, comfort and simplicity. Future predictor Richard Watson reckons that this trend will result in more commitment to buying British and local as opposed to foreign and global. Jasper Gerard the Times restaurant critic, and Mintel the research company along with many others feel that consumers will seek even more reassurance about where their food has come from, how it has been produced and what is in it, hence another reason for buying local. Animal health and welfare will also be prominent, especially pig welfare following the Jamie Oliver programme about pig production, scheduled for end January.

Linked to this trend come predictions from many, including innovation business the food people, of a return to home cooked simple food such as as stews casseroles and roly poly pudding, home baking, an increase in foraging, (the National Trust is running foraging weekends!), and an increase in gardening especially vegetable growing.

3. Worrying about the here and now as opposed to what happens down the road.

Some forecasters are predicting a turning away from environmental issues and products, unless they don't involve effort or extra cost, and are not a marketing ploy.

4. Trading down but some trading up too

These are Mintel's words and capture the urge consumers have, even in the most austere times, to break out and treat themselves. Certainly the continued growth in champagne and smoked salmon sales, and the news that Waitrose had a recovery in sales just before Christmas says that consumers will splurge occasionally.


5. Trend summary


Going Up:

Prudence

Staying in

Comfort food

Home cooking from scratch

Home baking

"Find your own food" from foraging to vegetable growing

Local, particularly if close in price to the alternative

Buying British

Cheaper cuts of meat, including a return to offal

Own label

Higher welfare options

Old fashioned, trusted brands



Going Down

Conspicuous consumption

Anything overpriced

Premium food unless very special, including organics

Eating out, except fast food

Bad service

Going to the pub


In truth, most of these trends have been emerging over the last few months, with the continuing flow of bad news merely accelerating them, and confirming that the choosy consumer is here to stay for a good while.

Saturday, 27 December 2008

Pros and Cons of a Locally Sourced Xmas Dinner



According to a recent report from Farmers Weekly Farmer of the Year John Geldard and Henry Brown of Westley Consulting the local foods market could grow from its current £2.34bn to over £15bn in 10 years.
A growing number of consumers believe that local food is fresher, of better quality, and a good thing because it supports local business. Many, though, think that local food is expensive and difficult to find.
To test the pros and cons of local food shopping we set about making a Christmas Dinner entirely from produce grown and reared within 10 miles of home in mid Warwickshire. Here's what we found.
Sourcing meat was no problem at all. Free range turkey, goose, and duck could be easily purchased direct from the producer's farm. There was a choice of both Limousin and Aberdeen Angus beef, outdoor reared pork, bacon and sausages, and home bred lamb. More intensively reared produce was also available for those choosing that option.
A nearby bakery made their own mince pies and Pudding as well as bread, we bought local Berkswell Cheese, and local free range eggs.
Getting good locally grown vegetables was another story. The local farmer's market was held too early for the veg to still be fresh on Xmas Day, and none of the farm shops sourced from close by. So it was off to the supermarket where nothing was local, but at least the sprouts came from Lincolnshire, the carrots from Notts, and the potatoes from Norfolk. Sadly the mushrooms were Irish, so they had to stay on the shelf.
But what about taste and price? There's no getting away from the fact that these locally sourced products cost more, sometimes alot more, than the supermarket equivalent, and there is a time and hassle factor involved in visiting various different shops. But the quality and taste was far superior. The Kelly Bronze turkey was outstanding as were the bacon and sausages, lamb and Aberdeen Angus beef. The Limousin beef was good too, and certainly better than supermarket beef, even from a premium range. The bakery items and cheese were excellent.
It was a reassuring purchasing experience too, with the ability to talk to the farmers themselves about their rearing methods, and see relaxed stock ambling about in fields or roomy sheds. In a couple of farm shops there was even someone on hand to advise on cuts to choose and how to cook the meat.
To this Christmas cook knowing exactly where the food had come from, and the quality, justified the extra cost and the time involved in sourcing locally.
But this way of shopping is not for everybody. Getting back to the Geldard/Brown report, they reckon that the growth they predict will only happen if local foods are pushed by supermarkets, the mass market catering trade, and the public sector. They are probably right. It would be possible to move local foods from niche to mainstream, and chasing mainstream volumes will suit some producers and growers. The trade off for the farmer is lower margins, and risk of losing control and independence. There would inevitably be a hit to sales in small local stores. And from the consumer's perspective, a very personal and rewarding way of shopping would be lost.
PS
On my shopping travels I asked each producer whether the difficult economy had led to a downturn in business. Most said that sales were holding up fairly well, although there were some signs of consumers trading down, for example from a Kelly Bronze turkey to standard free range,and from steaks and roasts to casseroles and mince. There was also a trend to buying meat to a price rather than a weight.



Thursday, 4 December 2008

Tesco Outgunned by the Competition - Some Reasons Why

So Tesco is getting outgunned by the competition. Third quarter results show their sales up by a miserable 2% compared with Sainsbury up 4.3%, ASDA up 6.9% and Morrisons up 8.1%.

The root cause is customer defection. An analysis by TNS the market research company, shows that in the 12 weeks to November, Tesco lost about £22 million of business to ASDA, a further £10million ALDI and just under £10million to Morrisons . Clearly "every little helps" is not helping enough. Why might this be?

There seem to be three reasons.

First, Tesco has a muddled consumer message compared with competitors. ASDA and Morrisons are known as value supermarkets. ALDI screams rock bottom prices. Sainsbury have stuck with a quality message. Tesco by contrast have responded to the economic downturn by adding a number of discount type products similar to those sold by ALDI and the like, but done little with their main ranges. So in the shopper's mind they are offering neither the cheap prices of an ALDI, or consistent value across everything in store like ASDA and Morrisons. And a slogan like "every little helps" means little to cash strapped consumers keen to hit a budget but reluctant to buy rubbish.

Tesco's prices are too high, and their quality too low. How do we know this? Just read the comments left by shoppers on newspaper articles about Tesco's performance. They tell of huge price hikes, inconsistent prices from week to week, promotions advertised but no product available in store to buy, and inferior fresh products such as bakery and fruit and veg.

And most telling of all, Tesco seems to have forgotten about putting customers first. Customers are outraged at Tesco's arrogant attitude and lack of service.

I'd also add that resentment about the way they treat suppliers is reaching boiling point. At the moment lack of facts means their alleged practices tend not to hit the headlines. This will change if Tesco is demonstrated to cross the line between tough negotiation and outright intimidation, and the publicity will do them little good.

There are lessons for all businesses from the Tesco story.

Successful businesses have a very clear marketing message, and they stick with it. Their actual product offer is often fine tuned, but they do not stray from their basic core principles. And they never, ever, take their customers for granted.

No one would bet against Tesco which is one of the most succesful businesses in Britain. Despite a slowdown in sales they remain almost twice as big as their nearest competitor, and their discount range is turning over about £1billion, which is nearly the same as ALDI's total sales. But they are not invincible, and if they don't learn the lessons then their performance will struggle.